Thursday, April 5, 2018

JP Massiah's Factum on The Motion to Set Aside Order Upholding Removal


                                                                                                                                                                                                                    Divisional Court File No. 316/15

                                                                                               
ONTARIO
SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE
DIVISIONAL COURT
B E T W E E N:
ERROL MASSIAH
                                                                                                           
                                                                                                                                                            Applicant

- and -


JUSTICES OF THE PEACE REVIEW COUNCIL and THE LIEUTENANT 
GOVERNOR   BY AND WITH THE ADVICE AND CONCURRENCE OF THE 
EXECUTIVE COUNCIL OF THE LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY FOR THE 
PROVINCE OF ONTARIO  and THE ATTORNEY GENERAL FOR ONTARIO
                                               
                                               
                                                                                                                        Respondents

- and-

RAJ ANAND and WEIR FOULDS LLP

Intervenors




APPLICANT’S FACTUM

E. J. GUISTE
PROFESSIONAL CORPORATION
Trial & Appellate Advocacy
2 County Court Blvd., Suite 494
Brampton, Ontario
L6W 3W8

Ernest J. Guiste (LSUC # 34970C)
Tel. (416) 364-8908
Fax (416) 364-0973 fax
E mail – ejguiste@yahoo.com

Counsel for the Applicant, His Worship Massiah                                                                                                                                                                   
                                                               
BACKGROUND 
1.         The Applicant, His Worship Errol Massiah, was removed from office by Order In Council 546/2015 on April 29 2015 following a hearing under section 11.1 of the Justices of the Peace Act(JPA Act)  before a Hearing Panel of the Justices of the Peace Review Council (JPRC – incorrectly identified in this Court’s October 4th, 2016 order as “the 2012 Panel”).  In fact, the 2012 Panel was the Panel chaired by Justice Vaillancourt which concluded with a reprimand on or about March, 2012.  The Notice of Hearing in the matter before this court was issued on May 31st, 2013 and filed by Presenting Counsel as Exhibits 1A and 1B in the initial set-date on July 4th, 2013 pursuant to paragraph 6(2) at page 20 of the JPRC Procedures Document – thereby declaring that the “complaints process will become public”.

            Order In Council 546/2015 (Relevant Docts Tab 3)
            Divisional Court Reasons (As above Tab 2)
            Notice of Hearing – Exhibit 1B (Applicant’s Motion Record
            Supporting Affidavit – Tab B)
            JPRC Procedures Document – (Relevant Docts Tab 8)

2.         The original Divisional Court Panel’s incorrect reference to the JPRC Panel which issued the removal recommendation as “the 2012 Panel” may be understandable in light of paragraph 14 of current Presenting Counsel’s Notice of Hearing which asserted a “history of judicial misconduct of a similar nature at a different courthouse” thereby subjecting the Applicant to liability for not only the complaint filed against him by prior Presenting Counsel, Doug Hunt, but for the “actual 2012” Panel’s disposition as well, thereby irreparably tainting the liability portion of the hearing since the Hearing Panel would have no jurisdiction to find liability on it – a point which was properly argued at first instance before the 2013 JPRC Hearing Panel and arguably properly conceded by Presenting Counsel but that the Applicant’s appellate counsel before the Divisional Court failed to raise.

           Applicant’s Written Submissions Part II
           Paragraphs 11, 25-33 (Applicant’s Motion Record
           - Additional Relevant Documents Not Filed with
           this Honourable Court – Tab 3, para 11, p.47, p 65
           Presenting Counsel’s admission re para 14
           (Applicant’s Motion Record – Supporting Afd
           - Exhibit “F”)
           JPRC Hearing Panel -  Decision, para 153-154
           and para 210
                                                                       

3.         Following a two day hearing, the original panel in this Honourable Court upheld the 2013 JPRC Hearing Panel’s decision on liability and penalty and remitted the compensation issue back to the said panel for adjudication in accordance with their reasons.

4.         Although counsel for the JPRC and the Applicant before this court were aware of the “full retirement” of the chair of the 2013 Hearing Panel, Justice Livingstone, a per diem judge of the Ontario Court of Justice, they failed to inform the court of this material fact prior to the “taking out” or formal issuance of the subject order of October.  The following statements by the Applicant’s appellate counsel in this court is both instructive and relevant on this motion:

           “I spoke with Scott Hutchison about the fact Justice
           Livingstone had retired, and that Ernest’s complaint
           against her had been dismissed for that reason, so how
           could she chair the reconvened hearing ?  He did not know
           about the Guiste complaint; he suggested that the SPPA
           provision about the remaining two panel members continuing
           the hearing would apply; but that he did not know (nor did I)
           whether that applies to this statute. He also said we could raise
           that before the panel when it reconvened.  I told him I would
           want to put that before the Div. Ct., before we took out the
           order, because otherwise the hearing panel would think they
           had a binding direction to re-hear the costs issue.”
           Affidavit of Raj Anand – Exhibit “W”

           “Errol, I wanted to confirm a number of things after our
           telephone conversation yesterday:

           2.         I have recommended that we agree to a modification of
                       the Divisional Court’s order so that it is re-heard by a
                       panel of two that excludes Justice Livingstone because
                       she has retired.  I understand that Scott Hutchison will
                       agree to this, and I have recommended this resolution
                       because the Court of Appeal has ruled in similar
                       circumstances that the thre(sic) member panel can
                       continue.  Therefore, our written submission on this
                       point are likely to be costly and unsuccessful.

         Affidavit of Raj Anand – Exhibit “Y”
           
5.         Twelve months following this Honourable Court’s order, the two remaining members of the 2013 Hearing Panel issued their No Unanimous Decision Regarding Compensation on October 25th, 2017.  Instead of returning to this court to address the issue the Chief Justice has appointed a new panel to hear the ordered re-hearing.

           Applicant’s Further Supporting Affidavit – Exhibit “I”
           Presenting Counsel’s Feb.1st, 2017 Submission
           No Unanimous Decision Re Compensation

PART I – THE MOTION AND JURISDICTION

6.         The Applicant judicial officer has brought this motion and a Notice of Constitutional Question pursuant to Rule 59.06(1), (2)(a)(b) of the Rules of Civil Procedure, s.6(1) and 10 of the Judicial Review Procedures Act and s.20(d) of the Statutory Power Procedures Act and s.52(1) of the Constitution Act, 1982, including the Constitutional Principle of Judicial Independence.  He seeks an order declaring the JPA Act unconstitutional; An order amending, setting aside, varying or suspending the Divisional Court’s order of October 4th, 2016 upholding the findings of judicial misconduct and the recommendation to the Attorney General for the Applicant’s removal from judicial office by a Hearing Panel of the Justices of the Peace Review Council and Order In Council 546/2015 dated April 29, 2015.

7.         The gravamen of the Applicant’s motion and Constitutional Question is that in order to be removed from judicial office in Ontario and indeed elsewhere in Canada he must have a fair and impartial hearing of the complaint of judicial misconduct against him by an independent and impartial tribunal and that this right continues when he asserts his right to seek judicial review of any such finding in a Superior Court.  Where this fundamental right can reasonably be said or appear to be tainted by any of the factors identified in his Notice of Motion, namely, a deficient record of proceedings, whatever the cause, divided loyalty and or conflict of interest of counsel acting for the Applicant or the tribunal, in the special circumstances of this case, ineffective assistance of the Applicant’s counsel, ineffective assistance of tribunal counsel, in the special circumstances of this case or bias, this Honourable Court can not be said to have judiciously discharged its Constitutional and statutory jurisdiction under the Judicial Review Procedures Act to provide the Applicant with a fair and impartial hearing of his judicial review application and any such order must be set aside.

PART II - THE FACTS:
Deficient Record Of
Proceedings Filed In
This Court:

8.         A Notice of Application for Judicial Review was issued on June 18th, 2015 challenging the legality of the said Order in Council in the following words:

             The Decision, Penalty and Compensation Decision, and
             all Related Interlocutory Orders should be quashed
           

             The Order in Council Should be Quashed
             (bb)      The Order in Council is predicated on the decisions in
                          the interlocutory motions, the Decision and the Penalty
                          and should accordingly be quashed as a result of the
                          errors of the Hearing Panel.

            Paragraph 4 of the said Notice of Application listed the 
following documentary evidence to be used at the hearing of the application:

          (a)        The record of proceedings before the Hearing Panel;
          (b)        The affidavit of Sandra Noe, to be sworn an filed;
          (c)        The Investigation Transcripts dated June 2, 2012 and November 1, 2012
          (d)       the letter from the JPRC to the applicant dated January 2, 2013;
          (e)        Such further and other evidence as counsel may advise and this                                           Honourable Court may permit.
           
          Notice of Application for Judicial Review
          Applicant’s Motion Record – Supporting Affidavit
          Exhibit “A” – Tab 1 A         
                                   
9.         Rather than file its complete record of proceedings, the JPRC filed, through counsel, a record   in which “more than half of the record formally acknowledged by the JPRC Panel on October 8th, 2014 including the Applicant’s answer to the allegations brought to his attention and the five volume investigation transcripts both of which would show that he was made to defend allegations of judicial misconduct at a public hearing not first made to the JPRC in a “complaint” in writing and investigated by a Complaints Committee contrary to the Court of Appeal’s decision in Hryciuk  v. Ontario.”

             As above para 38, 39 – Exhibit “V” – Tab V

March 15th, 2017 Confirmation
JPRC Retained The Record of
Proceedings:

10.       By way of e mail dated March 13, 2017 the Registrar of the JPRC was expressly asked whether they have the record of proceedings in their possession and she answered by way of letter dated March 15, 2017 – “This letter confirms that we have retained the record.”

            As above – Exhibit HH – Tab H

Hearing Panel Decisions
Clearly Cite Documents
Omitted from Record
Before Divisional Court:

Investigation Transcripts

11.       [66]      Therefore, we find that the investigators for the Complaints Committee had the authority to gather the Information about the new allegations and to provide the results to the Committee.  The transcripts from the witness interviews conducted in 2012 during the investigation were filed as part of the Record by His Worship.

            Decision on Jurisdiction and Alleged Abuses of Process
            Applicant’s Motion Record – Relevant Docts – Tab 4

Motion Records etc.

Identity of Complainant
12.       [33]      ....The narrow interpretation favoured by His Worship is inconsistent with the finding of the Divisional Court that the section “is designed to ensure that the process is open and public.”We support the view that complaints process is designed to be a funnel for concerns about judicial misconduct, not a fence.

            The Hearing panel goes on to cite the following after the above passage:

            Applicant’s Motion Record, Tab 2, filed July 12, 2013;
            Motion Record of Presenting Counsel, Tab A, filed July
            19,  2011(sic)
                                               
            As above
            Decision on Jurisdiction and Alleged Abuses of Process

Applicant’s Affidavit
Filed March 28, 2014

13.       Paragraph 142 of the JPRC Hearing Panel’s Decision on Jurisdiction and Alleged Abuses of Process clearly cites the “Applicant’s Supporting Affidavit, Exhibit F, filed March 28th, 2014 yet this document was not in the record of proceedings before the Divisional Court.

            Decision on Jurisdiction and Alleged Abuses of Process

Written Submissions of
The Parties on Jurisdiction

14.       [3]        The Hearing Panel has now received written and oral submissions from His Worship and Presenting Counsel on these remaining grounds.

            As above

Written Submissions of
The Parties on Liability

15.       [6]        Written and oral submissions were provided by counsel, with submissions concluding on October 8, 2014.
                                                           
            Reasons for Decision dated January 12, 2015
            Applicant’s Motion Record – Relevant Docts – Tab5

Written Submissions of
The Parties on Penalty

16.       [28]      ...We have reviewed the report, dated June 7, 2012, contained in Tab 3 of Volume 1 of His Worship’s written submissions on the Penalty Phase, which outlines the counselling in which His Worship was engaged as the Chief Justice directed.  We have reviewed, also, the documents contained in Tab 7 (from the same volume as noted above) which describes a one-to-one Remedial Human Rights session in which His Worship voluntarily participated on April 3, 2012.

            Decision on Disposition
            Applicant’s Motion Record – Relevant Docts – Tab 6




17.       The JPRC Hearing Panel expressly identified two reports which were involved in determining and documenting allegations of judicial misconduct. The first the Hunt Report which they determined to be the “complaint” and the second the “Investigators Report” – a document submitted by the investigators to the Complaints Committee and containing new allegations for their consideration.  They went on to conclude:

[67]      We further conclude that the Complaints Committee had the authority
              to consider the new allegations in those transcripts within 
  its mandate under s.11(7) of the Act and pursuant to the ruling in 
  Sazant, (supra), as  an extension of the complaint filed by 
   Mr. Hunt.

              Decision on Jurisdiction and Alleged Abuses of Process  
              Applicant Motion Record – Relevant Dotc. – Tab 4

Breach of October 8th, 2014
Agreement And  Open Court Principle:

18.       A letter dated August 19, 2015 from JPRC counsel, Mr. Gourlay to the Applicant’s appellate counsel clearly acknowledges three additional documents to be added to the record, including the “Investigation Transcripts”.  With respect to the inclusion of the “Investigation Transcripts”, Mr. Gourlay writes, “The caveat is that if these are to be put before the Court, they should be subject to a sealing order to safeguard the requirement in s.1(8)(sic)of the Justices of the Peace Act that “the investigation shall be conducted in private.”  By this I mean an order that would actually shield the materials from public access, not merely an order of non-publication in respect of the contents.”

            JPRC’S Counsel’s Letter dated August 19, 2015
            Applicant’s Motion Record – Relevant Docts – Exhibit “W”

JPRC Serves Fresh Evidence
Motions on Eve of Hearing:

19.       After all of the facta and Books of Authorities of the parties were served and filed with the Divisional Court the JPRC served two “Respondent’s Motion Records Re: Fresh Evidence”. Although the Notice of Motion seeks the following orders: 1. An order that the 5-volume “investigation transcripts” filed by the Applicant at the hearing below be added to the Record of the Proceedings as Volumes 8, 9, 10, 11, and 12; and 2. An order that these five volumes be sealed and not accessible to the public - the two supporting affidavits in the Motion Record deal solely with a letter which the Registrar and Counsel to the JPRC deposed in an affidavit was sent to Mr. Doug Hunt in satisfaction of part of the Complaint Committee’s mandatory statutory obligation. The other motion record deals with a letter the JPRC Registrar maintains was sent to Mr. Hunt to comply with a mandatory statutory requirement in the Act.

            JPRC Fresh Evidence Motion Records
            Applicant’s Motion Record – Part 3 – Tab 5, 6    

20.       The only order rendered by the Divisional Court Panel on the Applicant’s judicial review application is the order rendered on October 4th 2016.  No order was made to admit any fresh evidence.

            Divisional Court Reasons for Judgement
            Applicant’s Motion Record – Relevant Doct. Tab 2

Evidence of Ineffective
Assistance of Counsel
On Record of Proceedings:
Presenting Counsel
21.       Presenting Counsel, Henein Hutchison LLP, drafted the subject Notice of Hearing and was retained by the JPRC to present the case before the JPRC Hearing Panel against the Applicant pursuant to Paragraphs 2-5 of the Procedural Code for Hearing portion of the JPRC Procedures Document. They also served and filed the deficient record of proceedings although they were a party to the agreement on the scope of the record of proceedings on October 8th, 2014 before the 2013 Hearing Panel and continue to defend.

             Applicant’s Motion Record – Affidavit -
             Notice of Hearing – Exhibit “B”
             October 8th Transcript – Exhibit “F”


Respondent’s Motion
Record Re: Fresh Evidence:

22.       Counsel for the JPRC acknowledged in their Notice of Motion that the five volume investigation transcripts were filed with the Hearing Panel and they do not oppose the position that they ought to be part of the record of proceedings.  They sought a sealing order which was never acted upon on the basis of the assertion that s.11(8) of the Justices of the Peace Act mandates hat an investigation by a Complaints Committee be “conducted in private.”

             JPRC Fresh Evidence Motion Record
             Applicant’s Motion Record – Part 3 – Tab 6

23.       The Registrar of the JPRC confirmed in writing in response to written correspondence delineating the proper scope of the record of proceedings that they have retained it.

            JPRC Registrar’s Letter of March 15, 2017
            Aplicant’s Motion Record – Supporting Afd.
            Exhibit HH
                                                           

24.       Counsel for the JPRC and the Attorney General for Ontario 
  were unable to fully assist the court on their customary function 
  of delineating whether or not the tribunal’s decisions and 
  Presenting Counsel’s discharge of their statutory duties were 
  within jurisdiction.  In particular, neither of these key parties 
  informed this Honourable Court that in fact paragraphs 1-6 
  and 14 were not part of the complaint against the Applicant 
  and as such were never investigated by the Complaints Committee 
  and hence never ordered to a hearing by the Complaints Committee 
  to a hearing.  In fact, the Complaints Committee failed  to file a report 
  with the Review Council as appellate counsel, Mr. Anand pointed 
  out in his factum and consequently it is unknown precisely what the 
  Complaints Committee ordered a hearing on – if anything.

            Facta Filed by the Parties in this Court
            Applicant’s Motion Record – part 3 – Tabs1 - 3
            Applicant’s Motion Record – Part 1 – Investigation                                                          Transcripts

Evidence of Ineffective
Assistance Of Counsel
On Record of Proceedings:

Appellate Counsel  

25.       Appellate counsel was expressly notified of the Applicant’s concerns with respect to the sufficiency of the JPRC record of proceedings well in advance of him drafting and issuing the Notice of Application for Judicial Review and prior to perfecting the application – as he mentored the Applicant’s lead counsel on the first instance proceedings before the JPRC.

           Applicant’s Responding Affidavit – para 33-35
           Exhibits “E” and “H”
           Applicant’s Further Supporting affidavit – para 2
           Opinion – Sufficiency of Tribunal Record –
           Raj Anand Affidavit – Exhibit “O”

26.       On review of the Notice of Application for Judicial Review, the Draft Factum prepared for the Applicant, the Application Record filed by Mr. Anand and  Mr. Anand’s e mail to the Applicant on the eve of the hearing before this court three points are crystal clear. 1.  He initially intended to have the investigation transcripts as part of the record of proceedings whether or not the JPRC included them and 2.  He later left it to the JPRC to be filed in their Record as Vol. VII to XII.  3.   He was not sold on the privacy view which his junior and Ms. Henein’s junior reasoned was a basis for at a minimum having them sealed from public view.  He wrote, “I told him it was debatable whether they are private at this point, given the rules of the JPRC and the letter that went to the witnesses.”

           Notice of Application for Judicial Review – para 4
           Applicant’s Application Record – Exhibit “X”
           Applicant’s Motion Record – Supporting Afd – Tab A
           Draft Factum – Raj Anand Affidavit – Exhibit “GG”
           E mail to Applicant fr Raj Anand – Raj Anand Affidavit
           Exhibit “S”
           
Facta Prematurely
Filed:

27.       The following facta were submitted by the parties before the Divisional Court as follows:
             1.         Applicant’s Factum – dated January 13, 2016
             2.         JPRC’s Factum – dated June 2nd, 2016 (almost 5 months later)
             3.         Attorney General for Ontario – dated June 28th, 2016 ( 5 plus months later)
             4.         Applicant’s Reply Factum – July 29th, 2016.

               Applicant’s Motion Record – Affidavit – para 48
                                               
28.       A review of all of the facta filed by the parties before the Divisional Court reveals that they  failed to address the crucial legal issue raised by the Applicant before the JPRC Hearing Panel, namely, whether the Hearing Panel exceeded its jurisdiction by finding liability based on allegations which were not first made to the JPRC in a written complaint and investigated by a Complaints Committee pursuant to Hryciuk  v. Ontario and thereby failed to adjudicate the question which the statute authorized them  to adjudicate as Independent Counsel Mr. Gover advised them in his opinion.

            As above – at para 49
            Independent Counsel’s Opinion – (Exhibit “H”- Nov.22nd/17 afd)
            Applicant’s Motion Record – Part 3 – facta

29.       After this court upheld the 2013 Hearing Panel’s decisions on liability and penalty appellate counsel initiated a motion seeking leave to appeal from the Court of Appeal for Ontario based on that court’s authority in Hryciuk  v. Ontario [1996] 31 O.R. (3d) 1 although he failed to raise it here without objection by counsel for the JPRC.

            Appellate Counsel’s Leave to Appeal Facta
            Applicant’s Further Supporting Affidavit
            Exhibits “J” and “K” 
30.       In addressing this anomaly in his affidavit appellate counsel deposed that he did not refer to Hryciuk supra in this court because it was distinguishable and he felt that a professional discipline case, Sazant  v. College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario 2013 ONCA 727, argued by Ms. Henein and presented by Mr. Hutchison was more on point than a binding authority from the Court of Appeal on judicial misconduct which the 2013 JPRC Hearing Panel erred in applying.  Mr. Anand deposed that the conflict in these two Court of Appeal cases “would be a basis for granting leave to appeal.”

            Raj Anand Affidavit  - para 46-50

31.       However, Mr. Anand does not expressly argue in his facta that there was a conflict between these two Court of Appeal cases which needed to be resolved by that court.

             Raj Anand’s Facta at ONCA
             Applicant’s Further Supporting Afd
             Exhibits “J” and “K”

32.       Under cross-examination on his affidavit, Mr. Anand conceded that Presenting Counsel’s seven general allegations touching on the Human Rights Code concepts of vexatious, unwelcome and poisoned work environment were never pre-screened by the Complaints Committee.  He stated correctly, “They were not there to be pre-screened, “ and “The argument was that that was inconsistent with Hryciuk”.  He also properly conceded that Hryciuk was not in his factum in this court.

             Transcript of Cross-Exam of Mr. Anand – at p.65-66

Prejudice to Applicant:


33.       The following prejudice is suffered by the Applicant and the administration of justice as a result of the deficient record and the absence of the investigation transcripts from the record of proceedings:

            1.         Removal from judicial office contrary to natural justice and
                        fairness where the excluded evidence shows unequivocally
                        that the Notice of Hearing drafted by Presenting Counsel
                        exceeded the complaint determined by the Hearing Panel,
                        and the 2013 Hearing Panel failed to adjudicate the statutory
                         issue they were authorized by the Act to adjudicate;

             2.         The Applicant was made to face a set of new allegations in
                         the Notice of Hearing which were not investigated by the
                         Complaints Committee – involving allegations that his
                         conduct was “vexatious”, “unwelcome” and created a
                         “poisoned work environment”;

             3.         Even putting aside the jurisdictional point raised above, the
                         Applicant’s removal from judicial office is tainted by an
                         interpretation and application of legal concepts from the
                         Ontario Human Rights Code which departed in a material
                         way from both the Divisional Court and the Court of Appeal
                         for Ontario;

             4.         Before the JPRC Hearing Panel made a finding that Mr. Hunt
                         was the “complainant” and his report was the “complaint” as
                          those terms are used in the Act, the very allegations which the
                          Applicant was challenging since June, 2013 were receiving
                          widespread publicity in the press – the panel having denied
                          his request for an interim publication ban until the legal point
                          was adjudicated depriving him of any objective semblance of
                          a fair hearing; and

             5.         Public confidence in the proceedings which resulted in this 
                         judicial officer’s removal from office is prima facie 
             tainted by the fact that members of the public can not 
             review the five volume investigation transcripts and the 
             litany of other documents not filed with this Honourable 
             Court to satisfy themselves that he was properly removed 
             from office.             

Bias:
34.       Reasonable Apprehension of Bias and the denial of the right to a fair hearing was a consistent complaint advanced by the Applicant before the 2013 Hearing Panel and one which he specifically instructed Mr. Anand to advance before this Honourable Court.

             Applicant’s Supporting Afd (Nov.22/17) (p.2-24)
             Raj Anand Affidavit – para 10-13
  
L.S.U.C Nominee

35.       The Law Society Nominee on the 2013 Hearing Panel, Ms. Margot Blight, sat on the Hearing Panel for over five months – July 4th, 2013 to November 19th, 2013 before disclosing that she sat on a Complaints Committee which dealt with a complaint filed by the Registrar and Counsel to the JPRC, Ms. Marilyn King alleging he gave perjured evidence before the 2012 Hearing Panel.

           Notice of Motion(Bias) – Tab B
           Decision on Bias – Tab A
           Applicant’s Motion Record – Relevant Docts

Admission by
Presenting Counsel

36.      “As you are aware, Mr. Guiste is bringing a motion for recusal
           of Ms. Blight from the Hearing Panel on the basis of a claim
           that there is a reasonable apprehension of bias. While I do not
           agree with the assertion that there is any basis for actual bias,
           having considered the legislative framework and the JPRC
           Procedures, Presenting Counsel does agree that there may be
           a potential concern about the risk of an appearance of bias
           if Ms. Blight remains on the Panel.”

           Exhibit 17 at JPRC Hearing – Tab 10 p.277
           Applicant’s Motion Record – Relevant Docts

37.       The Applicant properly brought a motion before the 2013 Hearing Panel asserting various claims of bias, including Hryciuk Error on the face of the Notice of Hearing, the Poisoned Well Theory of Bias on account of Ms. Blight’s tenure in sitting with the Hearing Panel from June 2013 to November 2013.(she actually stepped down in February 2014 and that the Chief Justice exceeded her jurisdiction in appointing a substitute for Ms. Blight rather than appointing a fresh new panel. The Hearing Panel adjudicated the motion – ruling on the issue of the jurisdiction of the Chief Justice to replace Ms. Blight, dismissing the Hryciuk point and failing to adjudicate on the Poisoned Well Theory of Bias referenced in Roberts  v.  College of Nurses of Ontario 1999 Canlii 18725 (Div Crt) and cited at paragraph 41 of the Applicant’s factum on the said motion.

             Notice of Motion (Bias) – Tab B
             Panel’s Decision on Bias Motion – Tab A
             Applicant’s Motion Record (Relevant Docts)
             Applicant’s Factum (Bias) (Docts Not Filed) – Tab 11

38.       Mr. Anand deposed in his January 3rd, 2018 affidavit that he did not argue the Poisoned Well Theory of Bias with respect to Ms. Blight’s tenure on the 2013 Hearing Panel because “I explained that this issue could not be raised on judicial review because it was not raised before the Hearing Panel.”  This advice to the Applicant was clearly wrong and not borne out by the record cited above.

             Raj Anand’s affidavit – at para 12

39.       By letter dated February 1st, 2017 Presenting Counsel, Ms. Henein and Mr. Gourlay abandoned the 2013 Hearing Panel’s interpretation of s.4.2.1(2) which they relied upon to conclude on the bias motion that the Chief Justice had the jurisdiction to appoint a replacement for the Law Society of Upper Canada nominee, Ms. Blight.  In his e mail dated October 6th, 2016 – two days following the release of this Honourable Court’s order, Mr. Anand wrote to his junior that neither  he or Mr. Hutchison knew whether the SPPA provision allowing the two remaining members of the Hearing Panel to adjudicate the compensation claim applied to the Justices of the Peace Act.       

            Presenting Counsel’s Feb.1st/17 Admission
            Applicant’s Further Supporting Afd. – Exhibit “I”

40.       Another aspect of a reasonable apprehension of bias which the Applicant consistently advanced before the 2013 Hearing Panel was related to Presenting Counsel’s discharge of her statutory role pursuant to the JPRC Procedures Document.  The Applicant strongly argued consistently that Presenting Counsel exceeded her jurisdiction and these arguments are clearly reflected in the 2013 Hearing Panel’s decisions on bias and jurisdiction and abuse of process – starting as early as June, 2013.

            Bias Decision – para 53-55 – Tab 3A
            Decision on Jurisdiction and Abuse of Process
            Para 69-73 – Tab 4
            Applicant Motion Record – Relevant Docts          

41.       Mr. Anand acknowledges that it was the Applicant’s wish to argue in this court that Presenting Counsel exceeded her jurisdiction in the discharge of her appointment and that in so doing her acts and omissions impaired the Applicant’s fair hearing rights.  In moving in this direction, Mr. Anand’s  junior lawyer prepared a thorough memorandum delineating the excesses of Presenting Counsel.

            Applicant’s Motion Record – Supporting Afd – para 3-8
            Raj Anand’s Affidavit – para 93-99
            Applicant’s Further Supporting Afd – para 13 – Exhibit “B”

42.       Mr. Anand deposed in his affidavit dated January 3rd, 2018 that he did not raise this argument in this court on account of his concern “that the argument would be ill-received by the Court and that it could have negative consequences for the application.”

            Mr. Raj Anand’s affidavit at para 97

43.       The Applicant deposed in his affidavit and later at the cross-examination on his affidavits that neither Mr. Anand or his associate took the time to candidly explain to him the legal implications and consequences that would result if he asserted the legal claims he wanted advanced which would have permitted him to make an informed decision on their advice.

            Applicant’s Responding Afd – para 27-29
            Transcript of Cross-Exam of Errol Massiah – p.171 -191 

Human Rights Code:

44.       Presenting Counsel exceeded the ambit of her office by raising allegations in her Notice of Hearing which were never made to the Review Council, never investigated by the Complaints Committee and consequently the Applicant received no notice of those specific allegations until he received the Notice of Hearing which was issued May 31st, 2013 and filed with the Review Council on the first set date on July 4th, 2013.

           Factum filed by Applicant on Bias Motion – Tab 11
           Applicant’s Motion Record (Docts Not Filed)
45.       Mr. Anand acknowledges that the Applicant wanted him to argue the points raised regarding the Human Rights Code before the Hearing Panel in this Honoruable Court.  However, he maintains that he advised the Applicant that these arguments had no merit and he confirmed his advice in an opinion dated September 25th, 2015 – Exhibit “F” to his affidavit.

46.       This opinion fails to address the point raised on behalf of the Applicant before the Hearing Panel that his acts and omissions were not “vexatious”, “unwanted” and did not create a “poisoned work environment” – points which Presenting Counsel argued were present and on which the Hearing Panel did not adjudicate.

            Presenting Counsel’s Written Subs on Liability
            (Not Filed on Judicial Review) – para 1, 2016
 
47.       Although Presenting Counsel conceded that paragraph 14 of the Notice of Hearing she drafted was flawed in that this paragraph was intended to address disposition Mr. Anand decided not to raise this admission as a breach of natural justice or bias in attacking the liability decision in this Honourable Court.

            Excerpt of July 29, 2014 transcript – Exhibit “F”
            Applicant’s Motion Record – Supporting Affidavit

48.       Mr. Anand and his junior had communications with the Law Society of Upper Canada’s investigator regarding the complaint filed by the JPRC’s Registrar and instructing counsel,
            Ms. Marilyn King for which they billed the applicant.

49.       Mr. Anand asserts in his affidavit that these contacts were merely to update The Law Society of Upper Canada on what stage the proceedings were at and nothing more.

50.       The contacts took place after the memorandum on Presenting Counsel’s conduct and the draft factum wherein he asserts at para 61 that “the complaint, the “Investigators Report” and the NOH did not match and prior to the filing of the Applicant’s factum and Application Record in this Honourable Court.

51.       Mr. Anand’s account dated January 29, 2016 shows that one of the contacts involved a Weir & Foulds lawyer who once acted for the subject of the Law Society’s investigation on an appeal. On December 1st, 2015 following a telephone call from the Law Society investigator, Ms. A. Kirsh; and an e mail to R. Annd the factum is revised and a call is placed to M. Gourlay. On December 11, 2015 Ms. Peglar dockets a telephone call with R.Anand and the Law Society investigator, Ms. A. Kirsh.  Four days later on December 15th, 2015 Ms. Peglar revised the factum and instructed a junior for 2.8 hrs.

           Weir Foulds Account – Entry 30/11/15 (p.265)
           Entry 04/12/15, 11/12/15; 15/12/15; 13/01/16;
           14/10/16

52.       Mr. Anand says in his affidavit that he has been counsel on more than 50 applications for judicial review in this court yet he failed to resolve the issue of the scope of the record of proceedings before drafting and filing his facta.

            Raj Anand’s affidavit  - para 1

53.       The Investigation Transcript of the person whom the Applicant is said to have touched in the Notice of Hearing shows that this person could not remember any touching.

           Investigation Transcripts – Vol 3 – Tab 19 – Vol. 4 – Tab 28

54.       The following witnesses interviewed in the investigation did not witness any improper behaviour from the Applicant: A, B, C, D, E, F, G, H, I, J, K, L, M, N, O  and P*.

            Investigation Transcripts – Vol. 1-5                       

55.       The issues of “vexatious”, “unwelcome” and “poisoned work environment” were not probed on the investigation.
            As above
                       
56.       On April 14th, 2017 the Applicant learned from a publication on the internet that “current Presenting Counsel, Ms. Henein’s spouse was a law partner of the complainant in my removal case, former Presenting Counsel, Mr. Dough Hunt in and around the material time as Mr. Hunt acting as Presenting Counsel on my proceedings before Justice Vallencourt.

            Applicant’s sworn affidavit at para 60 – Exhibit “BB”
            Applicant’s Motion Record – Supporting Afd.

57.       At the same time the Applicant learned that Mr. Hunt was once the Assistant Deputy Attorney General for Ontario.
             As above – at para 61 – Exhibt “CC”

58.       In response to a clear question as to who is the complainant in the proceeding before the JPRC Hearing Panel Presenting Counsel expressly advised counsel for the Applicant in writing that the witnesses who she would call to testify are the complainants and the Applicant relied upon this representation to his detriment.

            As above – para 62 – Exhibit “DD”

Divisional Court Decision:


59.       The Divisional Court did not hear from the Applicant on the following issues: constitutionality of the Justices of the Peace Act and Procedures Document, bias, jurisdiction of the Chief Justice to substitute the Law Society nominee, Ms. Blight, whether Presenting Counsel exceeded her jurisdiction in presenting the case against the Applicant, the interpretation and application of Hryciuk  v. Ontario and the Ontario Human Rights Code.


PART III - THE ISSUES & LAW:
60.      
1.        Did the failure of the JPRC and Mr. Anand to ensure that this 
           court had a full and proper record of the proceedings below 
           impact the Applicant’s and the public’s trial fairness rights ?

 2.         Did this failure amount to incompetence in light of the 
            October 8th, 2014 agreement on the scope of the record of proceedings ?

 3.         Would the filing of a full and proper record have expanded the 
              nature and quality of legal errors which the Applicant could benefit 
              from ?

4.         Was appellate counsel’s failure to raise bias and Presenting Counsel’s 
             exceeding her jurisdiction detrimental to the Applicant ?

5.         Can this failure amount to incompetence ?

6.         Could any of appellate counsel’s divided loyalty issues have 
             impacted his representation or at the very least give the appearance 
             of having done so ?  

PART III - THE LAW:
Primacy of Constitution
of Canada:
61.        The Constitution of Canada is the supreme law of Canada, and
             any law that is inconsistent with the provisions of the Constitution
             is, to the extent of the inconsistency, of no force or effect.

             Constitution Act, 1982. s. 52(1)

62.        Any person charged with an offence has the right
             (d)       to be presumed innocent until proven guilty according to law
                        in a fair and public hearing by an independent and impartial
                        tribunal;
             Canadian Charter or Rights and Freedoms, s.11(d)

Record to be filed:

63.        When notice of an application for judicial review of            
             a decision in the exercise or purported exercise of a
             statutory power of decision has been served on the
             person making the decision, such person shall forthwith
             file in the court for use on the application the record of
             the proceedings in which the decision was made.
                                   
             Judicial Review Act, R.S.O. ch J.1 s.10

Content of Record:
64.        A tribunal shall compile a record of any proceedings in which a
             hearing has been held which shall include,

             (a)        any application, complaint, reference or other document, if any,
                          by which the proceeding was commenced;

             (d)       all documentary evidence filed with the tribunal, subject to any
                         limitation expressly imposed by any other Act on the extent to
                         or the purposes for which any such documents may be used in
                         evidence in any proceeding.
             Statutory Power Procedures Act, s.20

Right of Judicial Independence

65.       The Supreme Court of Canada left no doubt that as a Justice of the Peace the Applicant’s office is protected by the constitutional principle of judicial independence and that he has security of tenure – the essence of which mandates that his removal from office not be arbitrary or discretionary.  The existing conflict between the JPA and the Procedures Document which resulted in Presenting Counsel being able to draft a NOH which bears no relation to the complaint deprived this Justice of the Peace and indeed all Justices of the Peace in Ontario of security of tenure and financial security.   The fact that there is no obligation on the Attorney General to indemnify justices of the peace for the costs of defending their office in the same manner as their Provincial Court judge colleagues also makes the legislation prima facie  unconstitutional. 

                                                            Ell   v.  Alberta [2003] 1 S.C.R. 857

66.       It can not be the case that the Applicant’s constitutional right to a fair and impartial hearing of his removal from judicial office ends at the hearing conducted before the JPRC Hearing Panel which triggered his right to review under the Judicial Review Procedures Act. That Act provides no right of appeal and has no privative clause. As such, all that they are empowered to do they must do so in accordance with the law of the land and the Divisional Court is the court mandated by statute to sit in review of the discharge of their statutory function.

                                                            Constitution Act, 1982, s.52(1)
                                                            Charter s.11(d)
                                                            Justices of the Peace Act, s.11.2
                                                            Judicial Review Procedures Act. s.6(1)  
 67.      Where a tribunal fails to dispose of a matter before it in a manner permitted by the enabling legislation it is not functus officio.  When the said tribunal files a record of proceedings before a reviewing court which is incomplete for whatever reason neither the tribunal who fails to properly dispose of the matter or the reviewing court can be said to be functus officio – particularly in light of Rule 59 of the Rules of Civil Procedure.  Parties can not consent to make that which is relevant to the restoration of public confidence in the judicial removal process disappear.

                                  Chandler   v.  Alta Assoc. of Architects [1989] 2 S.C.R. 848

68        The Applicant and the public’s right to access to a tribunal’s record of proceedings in a judicial removal case in our system of justice is akin to the public’s right to inspect a search warrant and the information upon which it is issued after it has been executed.  Curtailment of public accessibility is justified only where the need to protect other social values is of superordinate importance. The need for confidentiality disappears once the warrant has been executed and in the judicial removal case once the Notice of Hearing is filed with the Hearing Panel as  per the Procedures Document in this case.

                                  Nova Scotia (AG)  v. MacIntyre [1982] 1 S.C.R. 175

69.       This Honourable Court’s jurisprudence of holding that parties are to file their facta only after the resolution of the scope of  the record of proceedings is well established and there is no justifiable reason to depart from it.

                                  Siera Club Ontario  v.  Ontario 2011 ONSC 4086
                                  Rowse  v. WPD Canada Corp. 2016 ONSC 5299

70.       A denial of a right to a fair hearing cannot be cured by the tribunal’s subsequent decision. A decision of a tribunal which denied the parties of a fair hearing cannot be simply voidable and rendered valid as a result of the subsequent decision of the tribunal.  The damage created by the apprehension of bias can not be remedied.  The hearing, and any subsequent order resulting from it, must be void.

                                  Nfld Telephone  v.  Nfld Public Utilities [1992] 1 S.C.R. 626

71.       “A reasonable apprehension of bias in one member of a tribunal is sufficient to disqualify the whole tribunal, even though that member merely sat at the hearing without taking an active role in either it or subsequent deliberations.  Mere presence is generally enough.”

            Roberts  v.  College of Nurses of Ontario 1999 Canlii 18725 (Div Crt)

72.       This court along with the Court of Appeal for Ontario’s jurisprudence is well established with respect to the test to establish harassment as “vexatious”, “unwelcome” and creating a “poisoned work environment”.  It is an objective test.

            Crepe it Up !   v.  Hamilton 2014 ONSC 6721 (Div Crt)
            Thames Valley District School Board   v.  Elementary 
            Teacher’s Federation of Ontario 2011 ONSC 1021 (Div Crt)
            General Motors of Canada Ltd.  v. Johnson  2013 ONCA 502 (ONCA)

73.                                           “I agree that the conduct must be unwelcome.
                                                Some conduct will be acceptable regardless of
                                                the reaction of an oversensitive complainant.
                                                Conversely, some conduct will be harassment
                                                even though there is no overt objection by a
                                                stoic or unresponsive complainant.  In the middle
                                                is conduct where the reaction of the complainant will
                                                be largely determinable of whether it is harassment.”

                                           Raj Anand’s Advice during Hearing – Exhibit “D”
                                           Exhibit D – Applicant’s Further Supporting Affidavit

74.       All defendants are entitled to effective assistance of counsel.  Effective assistance of counsel is a principle of fundamental justice – the denial of which renders a trial finding unreliable.  An allegation of ineffective assistance of counsel only succeeds if counsel’s acts or omission constitute incompetence and  miscarriage of justice resulted in an unreliable verdict or procedural unfairness.  Unreliability of a verdict is made out if the appellant can prove there is a reasonable probability the verdict would have been different if effective legal assistance had been received.

                                                R  v.  G.D.B. 2000 SCC 22 at para 24-28
                                                R   v. McKellar 1994 Canlii 1402 (ONCA)

PART IV - ORDER REQUESTED

           75         The Applicant requests an order declaring the Justices of the Peace Act unconstitutional and his removal from office based on it null and void.  Alternatively, an Order setting aside the order of October 4th, 2016 pursuant to Rule 59.

                                                            ALL OF WHICH IS RESPECTFULLY SUBMITTED.

February 28th, 2018

                                                                        _________________________
                                                                        E. J. Guiste, for the Applicant


SCHEDULE A
           


1.         Chandler   v.  Alta Assoc. of Architects [1989] 2 S.C.R.848 (S.C.C.) (Headnote only)

2.         Ell   v.   Alberta [2003]  1 S.C.R. 857 (S.C.C.) (Headnote only)

3.         Nova Scotia (AG)  v. MacIntyre [1982] 1 S.C.R. 175 (Headnote only)

4.         R   v.  McKellar 1994 Canlii 1402 (ONCA) (Headnote only)

5.         R   v.  G.D.B. [2000] 1 S.C.R. 520 (Headnote only)

6.         Hryciuk  v. Ontario (Headnote only)

7.         Crepe it Up !  v.  Hamilton 2014 ONSC 6721 (Div Crt)

8.         Thames Valley District School Board   v.  Elementary Teacher’s 
Federation of Ontario 2011 ONSC 1021 (Div Crt) (Headnote only)

9.         General Motors of Canada Ltd.   v.  Johnson 2013 ONCA 502

10.       Rowse  v.  WPD Canada Corp 2016 ONSC 5299 (Div Crt)

11.       Siera Club Canada  v.  Ontario 2011 ONSC 4086

  
SCHEDULE – B

1.         Justices of the Peace Act, R.S.O. 1990 ch.J.4 , s.11(18)

2.         Judicial Review Procedures Act, R.S.O. 1990 – s.10

3.         Statutory Power Procedures Act, R.S.O. 1990 – s.20

4.         Constitution Act, 1982, s.52(1)         

5.         Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, s.11(d)

6.         Rule 59.06(1), 59.06(2)(a)(b) of the Rules of Civil Procedure

7.         JPRC Procedures Document – Role of Presenting Counsel – 
Notice of Hearing – Open Court Principle – Public Hearing

NOTE:  This factum was filed with the Divisional Court in support of JP Massiah's Rule 59 Motion heard on April 3rd, 2018.  It is published here as a public service. All Ontarians are entitled to know what went on at that legal proceeding as it is a matter of public interest.  

*I have used letters rather than names simply to avoid any allegation by anyone that I have misconducted myself by naming anyone who they may believe ought not to be named even though my reading of the JPRC Procedures suggests that the Open Court Doctrine is clearly in play once Presenting Counsel files the Notice of Hearing - "the complaints process will become public, subject to any orders by the hearing panel."  The publication ban - issued by the Hearing Panel was limited to witness names of all witnesses which appear in the facta or motion materials in this hearing shall not be published." The June 11th, 2014 publication ban ordered by the JPRC Hearing Panel did not touch the names of persons who were not referenced in the facta or motion materials in the hearing. 

Monday, April 2, 2018

Justice Must Be Seen To Be Done

JP Massiah   v.   The Justices of the Peace Review Council et al - April 3rd 2018 @ 10 A.M.

Divisional Court - 130 Queen Street West, Toronto, Ontario - Limited seating



   This is a case of firsts.  

1.   The first case in Ontario's history where a judicial officer was removed for conduct determined to be inconsistent with the Ontario Human Rights Code while being denied the defences provided by the Code.

2.   The first and only case in Ontario since Hryciuk  v.  Ontario where a judicial officer was removed from office for conduct which was not first the subject of a complaint in writing to a Review Council and pre-screened and investigated prior to a public hearing.

3.   The first and only case in Ontario's long history where a judicial officer was compelled to defend a complaint where the complainant was unknown until after the public hearing was concluded and after seeking the advice of Independent Counsel dismissed the advice given them and failed to answer the statutory question entrusted to them - namely, to uphold or dismiss the complaint under s. 11.1(1) of the Justices of the Peace Act. (see Decision on Jurisdiction and Alleged Abuses of Process - January 12th, 2015)

4.   The first and only case in the history of Ontario's Divisional Court where a tribunal has filed a record of proceedings which omitted the document which was relied upon by the said tribunal to both order the public hearing and to identify the allegations of judicial misconduct thereby depriving the reviewing court of all relevant documents necessary to discharge its statutory and constitutional review duty.

5.   The first and only case in the history of Ontario's Divisional Court where subsequent to the Court's order upholding the said tribunal's decision as reasonable the tribunal acknowledges in writing that it has in fact retained the portions of the record which were not filed with the reviewing court pursuant to the s.10 of the Judicial Review Procedures Act.(Fresh Evidence - Exhibit HH - JP Massiah's November 22nd, 2017 affidavit)

6.   The first and only case in the history of the Divisional Court where the subject tribunal and the judicial officer's lawyer before the Divisional Court oppose his Rule 59 motion on the ground that they had an agreement which the judicial officer supposedly agreed to.

7.   The first and only case in the history of the Divisional Court where after an order from the court that the "2012 Panel" rehear the issue of compensation in accordance with the Court's order a panel with one fewer member deliberates for 13 months and renders a "no decision" and then requests the Chair of the said tribunal to appoint a fresh new panel to hear the case over the judicial officer's objection that they lacked jurisdiction to do this. The new tribunal proceeding to deny the judicial officer of the right to an oral hearing and the calling of viva voce evidence and for all intents and purposes upholding the first no compensation recommendation.

8.   The first case in Ontario's where an African-Canadian judicial officer has been represented by an African-Canadian lead counsel in judicial misconduct proceedings.

9.   The first case in Ontario where a lawyer who has acted with four other lawyers in the representation of a client has been singled out for professional discipline for steps taken in the said representation.

10.   The first case in Ontario where the judicial officer's lawyer before the Divisional Court had communications with the investigator from The Law Society of Upper Canada investigating the complaint filed by the tribunal against the African-Canadian lawyer to update them on the status of the proceedings between the drafting and filing of his factum and application record with the Divisional Court.

NOTE:  This piece is published here to draw attention to the multitude of issues of public importance raised by this little case.  I am counsel for JP Massiah.  I continue to represent him because I have a duty as a lawyer to do so especially since I believe that he is the victim of a miscarriage of justice.

If any fact in this publication is incorrect kindly bring it to my attention and I will correct it. The purpose of this exercise if to educate.

Saturday, March 31, 2018

Cogent and Compelling Evidence JP Massiah Wrongly Removed:Re JP Obokata 2003 and Fresh Evidence

   The argument that JP Massiah was removed from judicial office for irrelevant considerations and that he was subject to differential treatment is not a fanciful or frivolous argument but one borne out by JPRC precedence, the Human Rights Code of Ontario and The Rule of Law.

Re HW G. Leornard Obokata:

   In Re HW Obokata 2003 Justice Mocha of the Ontario Court of Justice found that this justice of the peace committed judicial misconduct by committing a sexual assault on a fellow justice of the peace. The following is her reasoning on the preliminary question which must be answered on the inquiry into whether or not judicial misconduct has been committed by a judicial officer:

FINDING OF MISCONDUCT

  "The first question is whether the incident amounts to misconduct within the meaning of section 12(1) of the Justices of the Peace Act.  Justice of the Peace Obokata's behaviour on May 2, 2002 constituted a sexual assault contrary to the Criminal Code.  Justice of the Peace Obokata intentionally applied force to Justice of the Peace X without her consent in circumstances of a sexual nature such that the sexual integrity of Justice of the Peace X was violated.  The force need not cause physical injury.  The purpose of the touching need not be for sexual gratification.  Any reasonable person would perceive the sexual context of the touchings by Justice of the Peace Obokata.

   Having committed a sexual assault, Justice of the Peace Obokata clearly misconducted himself within the meaning of section 12 of the Justices of the Peace Act".

THE COMPLAINT

   ...."Without any invitation or consent from Justice of the Peace X and without any warning, Justice of the Peace Obokata deliberately reached over and grabbed one of Justice of the Peace X's breasts and twisted his hand.  Justice of the Peace Obokata recalls grabbing her breast between his thumb and forefinger and pinching her breast. Justice of the Peace X loudly proclaimed, "Lenny !  I cant't believe you did that !"  Justice of the Peace Obokata then repeated the action."

GROUNDS FOR REMOVAL

   "The next question is whether the misconduct on the part of Justice of the Peace Obokata is incompatible with the execution of the duties of his office and has caused him to be disabled or incapacitated from the due execution of his office. Criminal conduct does not automatically warrant removal from office.  Justice of the Peace Obokata would have to be rendered unfit or incapable of proper and effective action as a justice of the peace as a result of the misconduct.

....As a result of the misconduct by Justice of the Peace Obokata, I find that public confidence in his ability to continue in office has been eroded by not lost.  I am hopeful that this confidence can be restored with some guidance and a great deal of effort on the part of Justice of the Peace Obokata. I have further concluded that a lack of tolerance for this type of behaviour can be demonstrated in this case through recommendations short of removal from office."

The Findings Against
H.W. Massiah:

[207]   However, we find that His Worship acted in a manner inconsistent with the Human Rights Code.

[32]   His Worship Massiah's testimony was that he did not at any time during the relevant time frame between May 30, 2007 and August 23, 2010 engage in any inappropriate conduct or make any comments towards any female in or around the Whitby courthouse which were unwanted, or unwelcome or which poisoned the work environment.


H.W. Massiah's
Written Submissions

Comments Welcomed

(18)   His Worship Massiah testified that he had no knowledge from his interactions with the court stafff that his comments were offensive, vexatious or unwelcomed.  He stated repeatedly in his testimony that he felt "well received" and had he received any hint of displeasure he would cease and adjust his conduct accordingly. (Testimony of HW Massiah at p.22-24, 41)


Justice Vallencourt's
Findings in First Hearing:

1.  The allegations in question took place between 2008 and 2010;*

2.  H.W. Massiah was not aware that his conduct was improper;

3.  No one brought it to H.W. Massiah's attention that his conduct was of concern;

4.  This was H.W. Massiah's first offence;

5.  H.W. Massiah had learned his lesson and would not re-offend.


Appellate Counsel on Judicial
Review's Fresh Evidence:

  In his sworn affidavit of January 3rd, 2018 appellate counsel for JP Massiah before the Divisional Court deposed that he did not advance the arguments involving the Code which JP Massiah advanced before the JPRC Hearing Panel and he delineated "the problems with advancing the failed human rights arguments" in Exhibit F to the said affidavit.

  Appellate counsel's opinion letter fails to address the Hearing Panel's interpretation and application of the concepts of "vexatious", "unwelcome" and "poisoned work environment".  His opinion deals with the limitation argument advanced asserting that human rights complaints ought to be brought in a timely manner and that individuals were required to pursue remedies through their union etc.

   H.W. Massiah deposed in his supporting affidavit on his pending Rule 59 motion and on cross-examination on the said affidavit that his appellate counsel failed to discharge their duty of candour to him and to enable him to make an informed decision on the matters they now assert he agreed to.


*The supposedly new allegations predated the Vallencourt Disposition.

NOTE: This piece is published here to draw attention to an issue of public importance. Our law must apply equally to all Ontarians without regard to race or any other irrelevant consideration.  Members of the public look to lawyers to advise them in areas in which they need guidance. When these members of the public become clients of their lawyers it is incumbent on the lawyer to provide the client with sufficient information in order that they may make an informed decision on their advice. It can not be sufficient that they blindly agree.








Thursday, March 29, 2018

Eight Key Facts TorStar Did Not Reveal in their Publication on the JP Massiah Case Today



1.   The Toronto Star appears to have been in receipt of the JPRC Decision prior to JP Massiah or his lawyer;

2.   $130,000 of the $770,000 fee in the Bill of Costs was for Massiah's appellate counsel who refused to raise bias and excesses of jurisdiction on the part of Presenting Counsel which he acknowledged adversely impacted the fairness of the hearing because he was concerned that "it may be ill-received by the Court".  This is now referred to as "Groia Chill" among litigation lawyers.

3.   JP Massiah's appellate counsel also failed to raise bias arising from The Law Society of Upper Canada nominee, who voluntarily recused herself from the Hearing Panel on account of JP Massiah's concerns about a reasonable apprehension of bias, tainting the balance of the panel since she sat with them from June - November, 19th, 2013 - some six hearing days.

4.   JP Massiah's appellate counsel refused to follow JP Massiah's instruction to challenge the composition of the Hearing Panel having two temporary members when the enabling legislation allows only one.  This lawyer's refusal was based on his erroneous understanding that he could not raise it for the first time on judicial review - believing that it was not raised below when in fact it could not have been raised earlier because only he was privy to the information on the status of the members of the Review Council.  This information is not available to the public of JPs subject to discipline until the JPRC's Annual Report is tabled in the Legislature by the Attorney General. The Toronto Star has written extensively on this failing by the Attorney General.(see Ontario is Keeping Secret Complaints About JPs - TorStar June 16, 2104; Ontario Failing to Release Reports of Complaints Against Judges - Torstar January 23, 2017)

5.   E.J. Guiste was JP Massiah's lead counsel and represented him throughout the proceedings.  Mr. Guiste had Mr. House conduct the evidence portion of the hearing on account of the Hearing Panel's blatant exhibition of bias and racial intolerance towards JP Massiah and himself which is well documented in the portions of the record of proceedings which were not filed with the Divisional Court and is the driving force behind the motion to set aside the Divisional Court order upholding the liability and penalty decisions;

6.   The Divisional Court ordered that the compensation re-hearing be conducted by the 2012 Panel. All of the parties before the Divisional Court were fully aware that the chair of that panel retired and therefore the 2012 Hearing Panel no longer existed but they failed to inform the Divisional Court;

7.   E.J. Guiste has argued consistently that the JPRC Hearing Panel lacked jurisdiction to conduct a hearing for several reasons and that was the purpose of the preliminary motions.  Had the bias and or jurisdiction and abuse of process motions been properly adjudicated there would not have been a hearing period;

8.   The JPRC Hearing Panel failed to answer the question which they were authorized by the Justices of the Peace Act to adjudicate, namely, to uphold or dismiss the "complaint" even though high profile lawyer, Mr. Brian Gover advised them on this point.


NOTE:  I continue to defend JP Massiah because I believe him to be the victim of a miscarriage of justice and that I am duty-bound as a lawyer to do so.   

Why The Fight Against JP Massiah's Removal from the Bench is a Just One

   On April 3rd, 2018 a panel of the Divisional Court is scheduled  to hear JP Massiah's Rule 59 Motion and Constitutional Question seeking to set aside an earlier Divisional Court order of October 4th, 2016 upholding a Justices of the Peace Review Council Hearing Panel decisions finding him liable of judicial misconduct and recommending his removal from office.

   It will be close to eleven years now since the alleged occurrences and close to four years since the hearing commenced on July 7th, 2014.  Clearly, not a prescription for fair and timely adjudication by any standard.  This point is amplified when one considers that a 2012 Hearing Panel chaired by highly respected Ontario Court of Justice, Judge Vallencourt made specific findings of fact that - 1. he was not aware that his conduct was improper; 2. no one had brought it to his attention that his conduct was of concern; 3.  this was his first offence and 4. he had learned his lesson and he would not re-offend.

   The legal and moral soundness of JP Massiah's Rule 59 motion is made irrefutably clear by the following passage in the Divisional Court's Reasons in support of their order upholding his removal:

[37]   ....While the factual findings made by the 2011 Panel are binding on the 2012 Panel, (for example, that the applicant engaged in specific instances of misconduct), the disposition has no such effect.

   All Ontarians who are interested in a fair and just society where The Rule of Law applies to all regardless of race or other irrelevant considerations will find JP Massiah's fight just and worthy of their support.  Arbitrariness and injustice to JP Massiah is a threat to justice for all Ontarians. It is as simple as that.  Who among us will be next ?

   I, for one, have been unwavering in my belief that JP Massiah is the victim of a miscarriage of justice.  I will continue to fearlessly defend him as a lawyer because it is my duty to do so.  Here is why I hold this belief even though the Divisional Court dismissed his application for judicial review by way of order dated October 4th, 2016:


1.  By decision dated March 12th, 2012 a Justices of the Peace Review Council Hearing Panel found JP Massiah liable of judicial misconduct and ordered a 10 day suspension and a reprimand.  In addition JP Massiah completed the following remedial actions: 1. Gender-Boundary sensitivity training; Human Rights training and writing letters of apology to all affected persons.

2.    Before that legitimate legal proceeding was even over some staff at the Durham Region Provincial Offences Court where JP Massiah also heard cases decided among themselves that the Disposition handed down by Justice Vallencourt was a "slap on the wrist" and that they would seek to increase it through a second complaint.

3.   The problem with their plan was that their second set of complaints were not new.  They either pre-dated or were contemporaneous to the first set.

4.    The first Disposition was not appealed by the Justices of the Peace Review Council. Nevertheless they retained high profile counsel to act as Presenting Counsel. Presenting Counsel's job is to draft a Notice of Hearing and present the complaint fairly and dispassionately.

5.   Presenting Counsel's first legal error was to draft a Notice of Hearing which had no relationship at all to the complaint. The Notice of Hearing included allegations which were not part of the complaint at all, including an allegation that JP Massiah acted contrary to the Human Rights Code by acting in a "vexatious", "unwelcomed" manner and by creating a "poisoned work environment".

6.  Presenting Counsel's second legal error was to incorporate the first Disposition into her Notice of Hearing in paragraph 14. This paragraph actually stated  "your history of judicial misconduct of a similar nature at a different courthouse.....demonstrates a pattern of inappropriate conduct toward women in the justice system."  To her credit, Presenting Counsel candidly acknowledged when questioned by per diem Justice Livingstone, the Chair of the Hearing Panel, "In my submission, that really was designed to address potential disposition." (see July 29th, 2014 transcript at p.110)

7.   Presenting Counsel's admission that paragraph 14 of the Notice of Hearing was intended for "potential disposition" did not cure the serious legal error flowing from this aspect of the Notice of Hearing.  In addition to the first Disposition JP Massiah was made to defend and found liable of numerous allegations that were not part of any complaint in writing to the Review Council and consequently not pre-screened by a Complaints Committee as mandated by our Court of Appeal in Hryciuk  v.  Ontario.

8.   A consistent theme advanced by JP Massiah throughout the proceedings was the glaring issue of a a lack of fairness and bias from the Hearing Panel as between himself and Presenting Counsel.

9.  Every legal argument advanced on behalf JP Massiah was rejected by the Hearing Panel chaired by per diem judge Livingstone.

10.   Although the Hearing Panel retained Independent Counsel, Mr. Brian Gover, to advise them on a jurisdictional question they raised in June, 2013 and which legal question they did not resolve until July 7th, 2014 - days before the commencement of the hearing, the Hearing Panel actually disregarded the opinion provided them by Mr. Gover, i.e. that it is a complaint which they are to adjudicate, and they went on the adjudicate Presenting Counsel's Notice of Hearing instead.

11.   On the judicial review which culminated in the upholding of the liability and penalty decisions, the JPRC failed to file numerous relevant documents which they had agreed at the hearing formed part of the record "for any proceedings which may follow" the Hearing Panel's order.

12.   By letter dated March 15, 2017, roughly four months after the Divisional Court order was formally entered by the Court, the JPRC wrote:

"Further, in an email received from Mr. Guiste on March 13, 2017, he requested confirmation of a number of items in relation to the earlier stage of the hearing. This letter confirms that we have retained the record."

13.   JP Massiah's written submissions on jurisdiction where this legal objection was raised was not part of the record before the Divisional Court.

14.  The statutory regime under which JP Massiah was removed, the Justices of the Peace Act, has a three-stage process. First,  a complaint in writing to the Review Council, triggers an investigation by
a Complaints Committee.  Second, the Complaints Committee investigates the written complaint and then reports to the Review Council under s.11(18) which reads, "The complaints committee shall report to the Review Council on its decision and, except where it orders a formal hearing, it shall not identify the complainant or the justice of the peace who is the subject of the complaint in the report.

15.   Disturbingly, the parties to the hearing before the Hearing Panel did not know who the complainant was until the Hearing Panel's decision on Jurisdiction and Alleged Abuses of Process rendered on January 12th, 2015.

16.   Further, although the Hearing Panel clearly relied upon the five volume investigation transcripts from the Complaints Committee in concluding that they acted within jurisdiction in considering the "new allegations in those transcripts within its mandate under s.11(7) of the Act" those transcripts were not part of the record before the Divisional Court when it determined that the Hearing Panel's decision on liability and penalty were reasonable.

17.   In responding to JP Massiah's Rule 59 motion to have the Divisional Court order set aside, his appellate counsel in the proceedings before the Divisional Court revealed the following in his affidavit sworn January 3rd, 2018:

1.  He did not raise bias involving the Law Society of Upper Canada nominee tainting the remainder of the Hearing Panel before the Divisional Court because he believed that it was not raised below. He was clearly in error on this point and the Hearing Panel's decision on bias confirms this.

2.  He did not raise the question of the jurisdiction of the Chief Justice to replace the Law Society of Upper Canada nominee for the same reason as above.

3.  He revealed in his affidavit sworn January 3rd, 2018 that he did not raise the question of whether the Hearing Panel was improperly constituted because it contained two temporary members of the Review Council because he understood it was not raised before the Hearing Panel and he could not raise it for the first time on judicial review. He was again in error on this point because the information on the status of the temporary members was not available until the first disclosure to him in an e mail dated December 4th, 2015.

4.  He revealed in his affidavit sworn January 3rd, 2018 that he did not raise the Hearing Panel's error in the interpretation and application of the Human Rights Code for reasons cited in a written opinion he provided JP Massiah.  That opinion is silent on the question of the interpretation and application of the Code principles of "vexatious", "unwelcome" and "poisoned work environment". The opinion focused on there being no limitation for the bringing of a complaint under the Justices of the Peace Act and that the persons subject to the conduct need not complain about it.

5.  He revealed in his affidavit sworn January 3rd, 2018 that he did not raise Hryciuk  v. Ontario as a bar to the Hearing Panel's jurisdiction because the facts of the case were distinguishable from Hryciuk.  However, he raised it on leave to appeal to the Ontario Court of Appeal.

6.   After preparing a memorandum on or about November 8th, 2015 for JP Massiah's review delineating numerous excesses of Presenting Counsel in the discharge of her duties as Presenting Counsel, including that she "acted as prosecutor and tainted the proceedings", "presenting counsel abandoned impartiality" and "although presenting counsel claimed that she did not intend to introduce evidence of the findings in the First Proceeding as similar fact evidence, this is exactly what was done....In by-passing a similar fact evidence application, evidence of the findings of the First Proceeding was introduced in such a manner that the applicant was denied the opportunity to mount  a defence to the similar fact evidence." - he deposed in his January 3rd, 2018 that he advised JP Massiah that raising these issues about Presenting Counsel would not be well received by the court and JP Massiah agreed with his advice.

7.   JP Massiah maintains that his appellate counsel failed to discharge his duty of candour to him and to put him in a position where he would have been fully informed and capable of making an informed decision on his advice he asserts he agreed to.


   The point being advanced on behalf of JP Massiah in support of his Rule 59 motion is simple. He was denied natural justice and fairness throughout the JPRC proceedings, complaint, investigation and the hearing. Presenting Counsel exceeded her jurisdiction in both the Notice of Hearing she drafted and in the tone and manner in which presented the case against him. The inconsistency between the Justices of the Peace Act and their Procedures Document which allowed Presenting Counsel to draft a Notice of Hearing without any overview by the Complaints Committee which supposedly ordered the hearing and without any order from them delineating exactly what it is that they ordered to a hearing makes his removal from office unconstitutional since it prima facie deprives him of the two fundamental benefits of judicial independence, security of tenure and the absence of an obligation to pay clause in the Justices of the Peace Act with respect to a hearing panel's recommendation for compensation of costs in defending the complaint - as is found in the Courts of Justice Act for judges of the Ontario Court of Justice deprived JP Massiah of financial security and places the cost of his defence on the backs of JP Massiah's lawyers at first instance. This is wrong. This has the potential of making lawyers beholden to the Attorney General in order to secure their fee.  This is serious and very wrong by any legal or moral standard.

   The JPRC and JP Massiah's appellate counsel before the Divisional Court assert that JP Massiah is simply a vexatious litigant and he agreed to all of this.  The Attorney General for Ontario relies on Res Judicata and asserts that JP Massiah was properly removed and if he wasn't it is Not in the public interest to correct this now.

Hearing:  April 3rd, 2018 @ 10 A.M. - Divisional Court - Osgoode Hall - Toronto, Ontario
(TTC - Osgood Hall stop) - across from the Sheraton Centre

NOTE: This piece is published here to draw attention to an issue of public importance.  For the first time in Ontario's history a judicial officer removed from office is seeking to set aside the decision upholding his removal employing the Constitution Act, 1982, including the Constitutional Principle of Judicial Independence and Rule 59 of the Rules of Civil Procedure.  For the first time in Ontario's history and likely Canada's too - a judicial officer was removed from office with a finding that he acted in a manner inconsistent with the Human Rights Code while at the same time being denied the defences under the said Code afforded all other Ontarians.  E.J. Guiste is counsel for JP Massiah on the Rule 59 motion.

If anything stated her is incorrect.  Kindly bring it to the writer's attention and it will be reviewed and if in error gladly corrected.  This is a public education exercise and not an exercise of placing blame on anyone.  History has shown that asserting blame only invites denial and a scorched earth response attacking the credibility of the victim.  Remember that women had no credibility until recently.  Black men had no credibility as well.  In this case JP Massiah is the victim in my view.

Tuesday, March 27, 2018

Did Standing and "Bootstrapping" by Justices of the Peace Review Council Taint Divisional Court Hearing ?

   In Ontario  v.  Ontario Power Generation [2015] 3 S.C.R. 147 the Supreme Court of Canada addressed the question of when it is appropriate for an administrative tribunal, like the Justices of the Peace Review Council, to participate in the defence of its own decision on appeal or judicial review.  In this decision the court seems to depart from the more rigid position it took in Northwestern Utilities Ltd.  v.  City of Edmonton [1979] 1 S.C.R. 684 prohibiting such participation primarily on account of concerns with the tribunal's impartiality.

   In Ontario  v.  Ontario Power Generation supra the Supreme Court ruled that a discretionary approach provides the best means of ensuring that the key principles of finality and impartiality are respected without sacrificing the ability of the reviewing court to hear useful and important information and analysis.  The court reasoned that on account of their expertise tribunals may be well positioned to assist the reviewing court. In addition, the court pointed out that in circumstances where there is no other party to defend the decision the tribunal may be in a position to help the reviewing court.

   The Supreme Court of Canada ruled that the following factors are relevant in a reviewing court like the Divisional Court exercising its discretion on the tribunal's standing to defend its decision:

1.  statutory provisions addressing the structure, processes and role of the particular tribunal;

2.  the mandate of the tribunal - is the tribunal adjudicative in nature or policy-making,
     regulatory or investigative ?

3.  does the tribunal acts on behalf of the public interest ?

   The Supreme Court of Canada clearly held that in exercising its discretion on this point a reviewing court, like the Divisional Court in Massiah  v. Justices of the Peace Review Council is required to balance the need for fully informed adjudication against the importance of maintaining tribunal impartiality.

"Bootstrapping"

   The Supreme Court of Canada addressed the critical issue of bootstrapping as well. The court pointed out that the issue of bootstrapping is closely related to the question of when it is proper for a tribunal, like the Justices of the Peace Review Council, to act as a party on a judicial review or appeal of its decision.  The standing issue the court pointed out deals with the types of argument a tribunal may make and the bootstrapping issue concerns the content of these arguments.

   According to the Supreme Court of Canada a tribunal engages in bootstrapping where it seeks to supplement what would otherwise be a deficient decision with new arguments on appeal.  The court was clear that a tribunal may not defend its decision on a ground it did not rely on in the decision under review.  Finality the court said, "dictates that once a tribunal has decided the issues before it and provided reasons for its decision, absent a power to vary its decision or rehear the matter, it cannot use judicial review as a chance to amend, vary, qualify or supplement its reasons."  The court went to express strong concern that permitting bootstrapping "may undermine the importance of reasoned, well-written original decisions."

Analysis and application to
Massiah  v.  JPRC:

Role of Presenting Counsel

   The JPRC Procedures circumscribed the role of Presenting Counsel.  Under this statutory regime Preesenting Counsel is retained by the Review Counsel to do the following:

- draft the Notice of Hearing and - "see that the complaint against the justice of the
peace is evaluated fairly and dispassionately to the end of achieving a just result". 
Presenting Counsel "shall operate independently of the Review Council."

   In Re Massiah the key argument is that the Notice of Hearing drafted by Presenting Counsel exceeds the complaint and therefore it destroys the key constitutional rights of judicial independence, namely, financial security and security of tenure. It is also inconsistent with binding legal authority from the Ontario Court of Appeal, namely, Hrycicuk  v. Ontario.  This point is eloquently stated in JP Massiah's factum in support of his Rule 59 motion in the following words:

2.   ....paragraph 14 of current Presenting Counsel's Notice of Hearing which asserted a "history of judicial misconduct of a similar nature at a different courthouse" thereby subjecting the Applicant to liability for not only the complaint filed against him by prior Presenting Counsel, Doug Hunt, but for the "actual 2012" Panel's disposition as well, thereby irreparably tainting the liability portion of the hearing since the Hearing Panel would have no jurisdiction to find liability on it - a point which was properly argued at first instance before the 2013 JPRC Hearing Panel and arguably properly conceded by Presenting Counsel but the the Applicant's appellate counsel before the Divisional Court failed to raise.

Presenting Counsel's
Admission - July 29th/14:

"In my submission, that really was designed to address potential disposition.

   Another key argument advanced by JP Massiah is that the JPRC Hearing Panel failed to follow various mandatory statutory provisions in their enabling statute which deprived them of jurisdiction to conduct a hearing into the complaint. The following is an excerpt from JP Massiah's written submissions on jurisdiction filed at the initial hearing (but not included in the record of proceedings before the Divisional Court):

[28]  Should "the complaint" be referred to a complaints committee, the committee must report to the complainant that it has received "the complaint".  It must also report to "the complainant" as to its disposition of the matter.  It is submitted that none of the witnesses testified that they had received communication from the complaints committee that their "complaint" had been received or as to the manner in which the complaints committee disposed of their "complaint", contrary to the requirements of the statute. 

JPRC Decision on Jurisdiciton
and Alleged Abuses of Process

Was the Complainant Advised by the Complaints Committee of the Dispositon of the Complaint ?

Positions of the Parties

34.   His Worship Massiah submitted s.11(7) of the Act requires that "a complaint in writing" must be made by a 'complainant" will will be informed that the complaint has been received and how the Complaints Committee disposed of the complaint.

35.  Presenting Counsel took the position that the complainant need not be informed of the disposition until the end of the hearing in front of this Panel.

Analysis

36.   We disagree with the position of Presenting Counsel.  Both the Act and Procedures are clear - it is the duty of the Complaints Committee to report its disposition to the complainant.

37.   In the Applicant's submissions, His Worship stated, 'The evidence will show that this did not happen in this particular case."  During testimony by the witnesses who provided specific evidence as to allegations concerning the conduct of Justice of the Peace Massiah, each was asked if they received any response from the Review Council (or Complaints Committee).  The answer was consistently in the negative.

38.   As we have stated earlier, none of the witnesses was the complainant.  Whether they intended to make a complaint is irrelevant.  It was Mr. Hunt who considered the information contained in the Will States of the initial witnesses to be a basis for a complaint.  He submitted the information to the Review Council.  As noted above, the complainant was Mr. Hunt.

39.  No evidence was led as to whether Mr. Hunt was advised by the Complaints Committee of its disposition of the complaint.

40.   In any event, we do not see the relevance in this proceeding as to whether this was done or not...


Rule 59 Motion

Non-Compliance with
Mandatory Statutory
Requirements:

Presenting Counsel
Conflict of Interest

10.   On April 14th, 2017 the Applicant learned that current Presenting Counsel's spouse was a law partner of the complainant, former Presenting Counsel, Mr. Doug Hunt, in and around the material time of Mr. Hunt acting as Presenting Counsel before Justice Vallencourt and the date of his report to his instructing counsel, Ms. Marilyn King, Registrar and Counsel to the JPRC thereby tainting the objective requirement of fairness in the proceedings contrary to law.

12(b)   Current Presenting Counsel told the Applicant that the "complainants" in his case were the witnesses who would be(sic) come to testify in a letter dated January 14th, 2014, which letter was part of the Applicant Motion Record on his motion asserting a reasonable apprehension of bias.  Accordingly, the Applicant cross-examined witnesses on this information to his detriment - the Hearing Panel ruling that their intention was not relevant as Mr. Hunt was the complainant.


12(c)   After the findings of liability, disposition and compensation, the Registrar and Presenting Counsel's instructing counsel, Ms. King, prepared an affidavit sworn August 19th, 2016 in which she deposed that she - as distinct from the Complaints Committee, complied with one of the two mandatory requirement of notice to complainants, namely that the "complaint" was proceeding to a hearing and that his evidence may be required although this evidence was never properly made part of the "record of proceedings" before this Honourable Court, resulted in an amendment to the Applicant's factum.

JP Massiah's Appellate
Counsel at Divisional
Court Purports to Consent
to "Fresh Evidence" of
JPRC Registrar:

   On the eve of the hearing before the Divisional Court - that is September 13th, 2016 - the hearing taking place on September 14th, and 15th, 2016 counsel acting for JP Massiah wrote to the Registrar of the Divisional Court in the following words:

"I am writing on behalf of the applicant with respect to the respondent JPRC's motion to admit a letter dated July 4, 2013, produced by the JPRC following receipt of the applicant's factum, as fresh evidence on this application for judicial review.

The applicant's position is that this letter, written by and clearly available to the respondent JPRC prior to the hearing under review, clearly does not satisfy legal requirements for the admission of fresh evidence.  Nevertheless, after assessing its significance, and in the interests of expedition, the applicant does not oppose the filing of the letter.

I would ask that paragraph 48 of the applicant's factum be corrected to read as follows, to conform to what we now know:

48.   The Panel had no evidence before it that the Complaints Committee had reported its disposition to Mr. Hunt or anyone else, despite the requirements of s.11(3) of the Act and page 5 of the JPRC Procedures.  The Panel rejected Presenting Counsel's argument that there had been no "disposition" at that stage, but treated the notification requirement as irrelevant and outside its jurisdiction. After th commencement of this judicial review application, the JPRC produced a letter from the Registrar of the JPRC to Mr Hunt dated July 4, 2013, notifying him of the Complaints Committee's disposition.

I have enclosed a replacement page 15 of the factum, which I will ask the Court's leave to substitute".


Divisional Court 
Order of Oct.4th/16:

   ON READING the Applicant's Application Record, the Applicant's Factum, the Respondents' Facta, and the Record of the 2102 Panel, and on hearing oral submissions from counsel for the Applicant and from counsel for the Respondents:

1.  THIS COURT ORDERS that the application for judicial review is allowed only to the extent that the decision dated June 16, 2015 is set aside, adn the issue of compensation is remitted back to the 2012 Panel for a fresh determination.

2.  THIS COURT FURTHER ORDERS that the application for judicial review in all other respects dismissed.

3.   THIS COURT FURTHER ORDERS that the Applicant shall pay costs fixed at $10,000 inclusive of all disbursements and HST to the Respondent, the Justices of the Peace Review Council, and that no such costs shall be payable to the Lieutenant Governor for the Province of Ontario or the Attorney General of Ontario.

Entered: November 15, 2016


OBSERVATIONS:

   An order of the court is required for the admission of fresh evidence on an application for judicial review.  The Divisional Court's order of October 4th, 2016 is the only order in the court file. That order does not grant leave for the admission of any fresh evidence.  The Divisional Court's Reasons similarly does not address any fresh evidence application.

   Although the JPRC's decision on Jurisdiction and Alleged Abuses makes clear that - "Presenting Counsel took the position that the complainant need not be informed of the disposition until the end of the hearing in front of this Panel" - and the 2012 Panel went on to conclude, "In any event, we do not see the relevance in this proceeding as to whether this was done or not" - Presenting Counsel, argued a brand new theory in its factum in this court.

Bootstrapping ?

   At paragraph 56 of its factum before the Divisional Court - the JPRC, and in reality Presenting Counsel, argued that "when a litigant asserts that a failure to follow a statutory requirement rendered the proceedings a nullity, there should be evidence that the requirement was not fulfilled".

   Presenting Counsel also served the parties with a "Fresh Evidence Motion" seeking to admit both the five volume investigation transcripts and the Registrar's letter dated July 4, 2013 to Mr. Hunt.


The Problem

   A review of the Divisional Court record conducted on behalf of JP Massiah did not reveal any order by the Divisional Court granting leave to admit any fresh evidence.  Although the JPRC - Presenting Counsel for all intents and purposes(Henein Huthcison LLP), served their Fresh Evidence Motion material on the parties before the Divisional Court those materials do not appear to have been filed with the Divisional Court and the Divisional Court did not adjudicate on them. However, a document in a sealed envelope with an affidavit of service attached tends to suggest that the said motion may well have been filed but for some reason remained in a sealed envelope and was not adjudicated upon.

   However, Counsel for JP Massiah acted on those materials and purported to consent to this and amend his factum.  Counsel for the Attorney General did not.

   Appellate Counsel for JP Massiah, not this writer, before the Divisional Court also agreed that the five volume investigations transcripts relied upon by the 2012 Panel in concluding at paragraph 67 of their Decision on Jurisdiction and Alleged Abuses of Process can be formally excluded from the tribunal's record of proceedings but on agreement be available in the court in case it is needed:

[67]  We further conclude that the Complaints Committee had the authority to consider the new allegations in those transcripts within its mandate under s.11(7) of the Act and pursuant to the ruling in Sazant(supra), as an extension of the complaint filed by Mr. Hunt.

Position of the Respondents
of the Rule 59 Motion:

   JPRC - JP Massiah does not meet the test for new evidence under Rule 59.06.  The record it filed was not deficient.  JP Massiah agreed to everything his lawyer did.  JP Massiah is not telling the truth with respect to the failings of his lawyer. The alleged conflict involving the relationship between Presenting Counsel's spouse and Presenting Counsel is not JP Massiah's to raise.

Intervenor - Lawyers are not required to take direction from clients.  Lawyers alone possess skill and competence in the manner of advancing litigation and it for lawyers alone to decide how the litigation will be conducted.  Appellate counsel discharged their duty competently.  JP Massiah agreed with everything his lawyer did. JP Massiah is not a trustworthy witness.

Attorney General - JP Massiah does not meet the test for new evidence under Rule 59.06. Even if the Applicant should satisfy the court that there was some defect in the process it should deny a remedy in the public interest.  They take no position on the facts alleged by the Applicant as against his own counsel or JPRC counsel.


DIVISIONAL COURT HEARING - SCHEDULED FOR APRIL 3RD, 2018 @ 10 A.M.- OSGOOD HALL - TORONTO - SEATING IS LIMITED - FIRST COME FIRST SERVED

NOTE: This piece is published here to draw attention to an issue of public importance. The removal of a judicial officer in our system is an issue of public importance that is recognized throughout the common law world and beyond.  E.J. Guiste is counsel to JP Massiah on his upcoming motion.

"I would be remiss in my duty as a lawyer to JP Massiah if I allowed this removal, in all of the circumstances of this case, to go unchallenged.  To remain silent is to condone what I believe to be a miscarriage of justice."



   






Saturday, March 24, 2018

R.I.P Althea Jarvis-Buntin - March 23rd, 1941 to March 4th, 2018



My aunt and God-Mother, Althea Jarvis-Buntin was born in Dominica in 1940.

Unwilling to be constrained by the absence of opportunity available to her in her homeland, Aunt Althea, whom I affectionately referred to as Nen, took active steps to free herself of the constraints imposed upon her and her siblings and embarked on her journey to Canada on the only ticket available to her at the time – the domestic ticket.

Nen – instilled in me the work ethic and life outlook which enabled her to arrive in her new home as a domestic and to leave and return to her homeland with her head up high – being fully satisfied that she had laid a solid foundation for the many others in the family who came after her.

Nen’s voice always beamed with pride when she recounted my answer when at the age of six or so she asked me what I wanted to be and I replied a lawyer.

Nen – instilled in me a thirst for learning.  Very early in my childhood she encouraged me to read.  I fondly remember compiling several issues of her Readers Digest magazines at a time for me to take home and read. I made it a point to read things that I was not particularly familiar with simply to expand my knowledge.  I took a keen interest in a portion of the magazine which featured stories about various organs or parts of the body – which typically had titles like Joe’s Liver etc.  I had read so many of those articles that I had at one point set my sights on becoming a surgeon.

Nen – ensured that my thirst for knowledge was not short-lived.  She was a gifted teacher and motivator.  I remember at one point taking a great dislike of taking a bath. She found a quick and easy remedy.  She bought me a beautiful sailboat complete with a sweet smelling soap to spruce up my bath time.  It worked. I enjoyed many a long bath with my new sail boat.  As I grew older and encountered new people, new ideas, new cuisine Nen somehow managed to rid me of my bad habits and narrow world views.  My habit of rejecting foods I was not familiar with ended.  I ultimately became a lover of most foods and if not giving it a taste and a very polite no thanks.

Nen took a special joy and pride in bringing happiness and comfort to others.  I saw this firsthand as a child growing up with her. She always made it point to get us two or three gifts. One was not enough.  She always knew what gifts to get us too. I later saw the demonstration of her love and warmth spirit when I had the opportunity to live with her and Uncle Ken when I graduated from McGill U and was in search of a new life in Ontario.  She enjoyed a large and varied circle of friends and she took great pride and interest in frequently entertaining. I recall meeting the late Dr. Liverpool – uncle Ken’s cousin and him taking me to a party at the late Edward Greenspan’s home. I recall meeting the noted author Austin Clarke at her home.

Nen was the mother I did not have.  When I started dating she took a keen interest in meeting with and talking to me about my girlfriends.  I remember her taking myself and a particular girlfriend for dinner in Montreal. She was classy, engaging and down-to-earth.  She possessed a keen ability to read people.  She carried herself with a sense of dignity and self confidence which allowed her to sit down and debate issues of the day with anyone, including one of my most argumentative colleagues, who now goes by the initials M.A.A.W.

Music has a way of colouring and making more vivid certain memories.  Nen loved to sing Linda Ronstadt’s Blue Bayou. I remember it like it was yesterday. I was spending Christmas holidays with her in Toronto. She and Uncle Ken lived in an apartment on Neptune Drive. That song was a huge hit at the time. It played frequently on the airwaves.

Then and many, many years after Nen would often belt out those lyrics –

I feel so bad I got a worried mind.
I’M so lonesome all the time
Since I left my baby behind on Blue Bayou

Saving nickels saving dimes
working till the sun don’t shine
Looking forward to happier times on Blue Bayou

I’m going back someday
Come what may
To Blue Bayou
Where the folks are fine
And the world is mine
On Blue Bayou
Where those fishing boats
With their sails afloat
If I could only see
That familiar sunrise
Through sleepy eyes
How happy I’d be… 

    Another one of her favorite songs was “The Lady in Red” by Chris De Burgh. She often sang this one with the utmost of passion.

I’ve never seen you looking so lovely as you did tonight,
I’ve never seen you shine so bright,
I’ve never seen so many men ask you if you wanted to dance,
They’re looking for a little romance, given half a chance,
And I have never seen that dress you’re wearing,
Or the highlights in your hair that catch your eyes,
I have been blind,

The lady in red is dancing with me, cheek to cheek.
There’s nobody here, its just you and me,
It’s where I want to be,
But I hardly know this beauty by my side,
I’ll never forget the way you look tonight;

I will always remember and cherish the great memories.  When I arrived in Canada from Dominica on the 8th of January 1972 – Nen threw me a dashing birthday party for my 8th birthday – (February 13th) – complete with party hats and noisemakers.

I will always remember the taste and aroma of her Christmas fruit cake. Until very recently, Nen made it a point of sending me a Christmas cake every year.

Nen taught me to love and be loved. She taught me how to look for and appreciate what really matters in a person.

It aches me so that you had to endure such suffering before you left us.  However, after speaking to you just days prior to your passing I felt a sense of calm and comfort in knowing that you were at peace with yourself, your plight and your creator.  I took great comfort in the reason and dignity you displayed in our talk. You acknowledged that your plight was all part of life and that you had had a good life.

I can not thank you enough for what you have done for me and indeed the entire family.  You gave tirelessly and selflessly of yourself.  I am eternally indebted to you.  You are gone in the flesh but your spirit and my memories of you shall stay with me until I come to pass.

Rest in Peace my sweet Nen !   Rest in peace !

 March 22nd, 2018