Monday, April 30, 2018

Does a Client Have the Right to the Undivided Loyalty of his Lawyer in a JR of Removal from Office Case ?


                                                                  Court of Appeal File No.M49113
                                                                  Divisional Court File No. 316/15
                                                                                                           

COURT OF APPEAL FOR ONTARIO



ERROL MASSIAH
Applicant/Moving Party

-and-


THE JUSTICES OF THE PECE RVIEW COUNCIL and THE LIEUTENANT GOVERNOR BY AND WITH THE ADVICE AND CONCURRENCE OF THE EXECUTIVE COUNCIL OF THE LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY FOR THE PROVINCE OF ONTARIO and THE ATTORNEY GENERAL FOR ONTARIO
Respondents

- and –

RAJ ANAND and WEIR FOULDS LLP

Intervenors

 NOTICE OF MOTION FOR LEAVE TO APPEAL

          THE MOVING PARTY, Errol Massiah, will make a motion to the Court of Appeal for Ontario for leave to appeal the decision of the Divisional Court dated April 9th, 2018.

                   PROPOSED METHOD OF HEARING is in writing 36 days after service of the moving party’s motion record, factum and transcripts, if any, or on the filing of the moving party’s reply factum, if any, whichever is earlier, at Osgoode Hall, 130 Queen Street West, Toronto, Ontario, M5H 2N5, pursuant to rule 61.03.1(1) of the Rules of Civil Procedure.

                   The Motion is for:

1.      An order granting the moving party leave to appeal to the Court of Appeal for Ontario from the decision of the Divisional Court dated April 9th, 2018;

2.      His costs; and

3.      Such further and other relief as counsel may advise and this Honourable Court permit.

                   THE GROUNDS FOR THIS MOTION ARE:

(1) The Original Decisions:

1.      By Order dated October 4th, 2016, the Divisional Court dismissed an application for judicial review brought by the Applicant seeking to quash the decision, penalty, compensation decision, Order-in-Council and all interlocutory decisions of a Hearing Panel of the Justices of the Peace Review Council which recommended the Applicant’s removal as a Justice of the Peace.  Leave to appeal that decision was sought at the Ontario Court of Appeal and that motion was denied.

2.      Throughout those proceedings (judicial review and leave to appeal motion) the Applicant was represented by the Intervenors.

3.      Following the dismissal of the proceedings, the Applicant sought the advice of other counsel regarding what he considered a most unjust result in the circumstances.  At that time it was discovered that the intervenors had been quite ineffective on a number of fundamental points of law and indeed had a conflict of interest in their representation of the Applicant which deprived him of natural justice and to a fair and impartial adjudication of his right to have the Divisional Court supervise the Justices of the Peace Review Council Hearing Panel’s exercise of their statutory power of decision under the Judicial Review Procedures Act.

4.      Following the dismissal of the proceedings, the Applicant learned that Presenting Counsel’s spouse in the proceedings before the Justices of the Peace Review Council Hearing Panel was a law partner of the complainant, Mr. Doug Hunt, in the hearing she acted as Presenting Counsel in which resulted in his removal.   Standing alone this may not raise concerns of fairness.  However, Presenting Counsel was expressly asked in writing who the complainant was in the case and she advised in writing that it was the witnesses who she  would call the hearing.  Relying on this representation the Applicant asked every witness whether they had any intention to complain about him and they all answered in the negative with the Hearing Panel making a finding that this point was not relevant because Mr. Hunt was the complainant.

5.      Remarkably, the hearing proceeded to a finding of liability without the Applicant knowing who the complainant was.  In addition, although seeking the advice of Independent Counsel who specifically advised them in his opinion that it was a “complaint” which the Justices of the Peace Act authorized them to adjudicate they proceeded to adjudicate the counts on Presenting Counsel’s Notice of Hearing.

6.      A motion and Notice of Constitutional Question was brought before a three member panel of the Divisional Court seeking to set aside the decision of the Divisional Court as a miscarriage of justice citing the following sources of jurisdiction: s.6(1) and 10 of the Judicial Review Procedures Act and s.20(d) of the Statutory Power Procedures Act, s.51(1) of the Constitution Act, 1982 and Rule 59.06(1) and 59.06(2)(a)(b) of the Rules of Civil Procedure.

April 9th, 2018
Divisional Court
Decision:

7.      On April 9th, 2018 a panel of the Divisional Court dismissed the Applicant’s Notice of Constitutional Question seeking a declaration of unconstitutionality arising from a conflict between the in-writing complaint provision mandated by s.10.2(2) of the Justices of the Peace Act and the Notice of Hearing provisions of the Procedures Document which allow an unfettered discretion to Presenting Counsel retained by the Justices of the Peace Review Council to present the case to also draft a Notice of Hearing having no relation to the complaint and even to assert liability for matters in a prior hearing which were clearly res judicata;

 8.      In addition, the Divisional Court Panel dismissed and or failed to consider the Applicant’s claim that the Hearing Panel which recommended his removal was chaired by a part-time judge who required the consent of the Attorney General to sit as a judge and was composed of two “temporary members” of the Review Council contrary to the Justices of the Peace and Procedures Document.

9.      Further, the panel of the Divisional Court dismissed the Applicant’s Notice of Constitutional Question seeking a declaration that the compensation-for-legal-costs portion of the Justices of the Peace Act is unconstitutional since the legislation has no statutory language requiring the Attorney General of Ontario to pay compensation on any recommendation for compensation involving a justice of the peace – while s.51.7(8) of the Courts of Justice Act contains mandatory language directing the Attorney General to pay compensation to Judges of the Ontario Court of Justice pursuant to any recommendation made by a Hearing Panel.

10.    By order dated April 9th, 2018 a panel of the Divisional Court dismissed the Applicant’s motion seeking to set aside, vary or amend a decision of another panel of the Divisional Court dated October 4th, 2016 expressly finding the decisions of liability and penalty of a Hearing Panel of the Justices of the Peace Review Council reasonable based on the record of proceedings before it, as a miscarriage of justice.

11.    Further, the said panel of the Divisional Court also dismissed the Applicant’s prayer for the following relief:

                   i.        An order declaring his appellate counsel on
                             the October 4th, 2016 order to have been in
                             a personal conflict of interest;

                   ii.       An order declaring his appellate counsel to 
                             have provided him ineffective assistance of 
                             counsel thereby depriving him of his 
                             constitutional right to a fair and impartial 
                             hearing of the review by a Superior Court
                             of his removal from judicial office;

                   iii.      An order declaring that Presenting Counsel 
                             exceeded the statutory ambit of her duties as 
                             Presenting Counsel under the Justices of the 
                             Peace Review Council’s Procedures Document 
                             and in so doing deprived the Hearing Panel 
                             with effective assistance of counsel and or
                             improperly interfered with the Applicant’s right 
                             to counsel and his right to defend his judicial 
                             office as is his constitutional right so to do;

                   iv.      An order declaring Henein Hutchison LLP to 
                             be in a conflict of interest and consequently 
                             disqualified from defending the decisions of 
                             The Justices of the Peace Review Council 
                             Hearing Panel’s decisions in this matter
                             since the challenged acts and omissions 
                             flow from their discharge of the function 
                             of Presenting Counsel before the Hearing 
                             Panel and the filling of the tribunal’s record 
                             of proceedings and it is for the Attorney 
                             General of Ontario to exercise his common 
                             law, constitutional and statutory Jurisdiction 
                             under the Ministry of the Attorney General
                             Act in the public interest.       


Cogent Reason to
Doubt Correctness
Of order:

Admittedly Deficient
Record:

12.    The Applicant’s motion while invoking Rule 59 with respect to various discrete items of fresh evidence raised a more fundamental point which  recognizes the fundamental role of the Superior Court in the adjudication of an application for judicial review which is to supervise the statutory exercise of power and to ensure that it was lawful. In this case, the Divisional Court upheld the Hearing Panel’s decisions of liability and penalty finding them not to be correct but to be reasonable based on the record before it;

13.    The April 9th, 2018 decision was made notwithstanding the following facts before the court:

                   i.        Breach of agreement by the parties before 
                             the Hearing Panel on the scope of the 
                             record of proceedings which is clearly 
                             reflected in the October 8th, 2014
                             transcript of the JPRC hearing;

                   ii.       A March 15th, 2017 written confirmation 
                             from the Registrar and Counsel of the Justices 
                             of the Peace Review confirming that they have 
                             in their possession the five volume investigation 
                             transcripts, exhibits 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 
                             12, 13A, 13B, 13C, 13D, 14A, 14B, 14C, 14D, 
                             14E, 14F, 14G, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 
                             24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30A, 30B, 30C and copies 
                             of all motion records, facta and boa;  and

                   iii.      A sworn affidavit from co-counsel for the JPRC 
                             that he and the Applicant’s appellate counsel on 
                             the judicial review hearing before the Divisional 
                             Court agreed after the parties had all filed their 
                             facta with the court that the five volume 
                             investigation transcripts would not be filed with 
                             the court but “would be made available to be 
                             passed up to the court if necessary”

Conflict with Jurisprudence
From this court:

14.    In Payne  v. Ontario Human Rights Commissions 2000 Canli 5731 (ONCA) the court stated:

                   [161]   An Applicant for judicial review has the right 
                               to have a full and accurate record of what went 
                               on before the tribunal put before the court. 
                               This is an aspect of the superior court’s inherent 
                               powers of judicial review... A statutory body 
                               subject to judicial review cannot immunize itself 
                               or its process by arriving at decisions
                               on considerations that are not revealed by the 
                               record it files with the court.

15.    In the April 9th, 2018 the Divisional Court Panel ruled that “Rule 59.06 does not apply to any of these matters. The Applicant knew of all of these issues and complaints before the entry of the October 2016 Order.”
         
16.    In Aird & Berlis LLP  v. Oravital Inc. 2018 ONCA 164 this Honourable Court set aside a motions judge’s finding that the appellants’ were sophisticated business people who were aware of the value of the damages and risks of litigation stating that it reflects a misapprehension of a lawyer’s duty of care to advise the clients about the legal basis for the damages and the risks of litigation. In addition, although the parties took the position that the issues for litigation could be resolved on a motion for summary judgement the court held that they were mistaken on that point and ordered a trial of the matters.

17.    Under s.10 of Judicial Review Procedure Act the duty to file the tribunal’s record is on “the person making the decision” as distinct from that person’s counsel or as in this case the law firm retained to perform the statutory function of Presenting Counsel pursuant to the JPRC Procedures Document.

Standing and Boot-Strapping:

18.    In Ontario  v. Ontario Power Generation [2015] 3 S.C.R. 147 the Supreme Court of Canada provided guidelines on the issues of tribunal standing to defend their own decision on judicial review and on boot-strapping, supplementing their decision with new arguments on appeal.

19.    The JPRC Procedures expressly provide that the role of Presenting Counsel, Henein Hutchision LLP is “to see that complaint against the justice of the peace is evaluated fairly and dispassionately to the end of achieving a just result”, a function which is long spent.

Conflict of Interest
Of Applicant’s Counsel
On Judicial Review:

20.    The April 9th, 2018 decision overlooked the following salient facts which placed the Applicant’s counsel on the judicial review in a conflict of interest or position of divided loyalty:

                             1.      He was an integral part of the Applicant’s
                                      legal team at the JPRC Hearing;

                             2.      Prior to the JPRC Hearing Panel making 
                                      its referral of the Applicant’s lead counsel 
                                      to the Law Society of Upper Canada 
                                      alleging, among other things, that he brought 
                                      meritless motions, that lawyer referred the 
                                      judicial review to him;

                             3.      He and his firm have historically been the
                                      counsel of choice for the subject lawyer,
                                      including on a reported case touching on
                                      that lawyer’s conduct;

                             4.      His initial draft of the Notice of Application 
                                      for Judicial Review and indeed the issued 
                                      document show a clear intention to challenge 
                                      the JPRC Hearing Panel’s errors in the 
                                      adjudication of the preliminary motions 
                                      attributed to the said lawyer;

                             5.      On June 22nd, 2015 the JPRC issued a
                                      Compensation Decision and Addendum
                                      alleging professional misconduct on the
                                      part of the Applicant’s lead counsel touching
                                      on the merits of legal arguments raised at
                                      the hearing;
  
                             6.      The Applicant was clear in his 
                                       instructions to counsel prosecuting 
                                       the Judicial review application that 
                                       the Hearing Panel’s adjudication of 
                                       the preliminary motions
                                      was in error and was evidence of the 
                                      Hearing Panel’s exhibition of a 
                                      reasonable apprehension of bias based 
                                      on his and his lead counsel’s race;

                             7.      At no time did the Applicant’s counsel on the
                                      Judicial review advise him that the Hearing
                                      Panel’s referral of his lead counsel to The
                                      Law Society of Upper Canada, where he sits
                                      as both a Bencher and Adjudicator on the 
                                      Law Society Tribunal placed him in a conflict 
                                      or position of divided loyalty which resulted 
                                      in the following acts of ineffective assistance 
                                      of counsel on their part:

                                               
    1.     Abandoning the argument that 
            the complaint, the Investigators
            Report and the Notice of Hearing
            did not match;

    2.      Abandoning the argument that 
             The Decision, Penalty and 
             Compensation Decision, and all 
             related interlocutory orders 
             should be quashed;

    3.      Abandoning the argument that 
             the Order in Council is predicated 
             on the decisions in the interlocutory 
             motions, the Decision and the Penalty 
             and should accordingly be quashed 
             as a result of the errors by the 
             Hearing Panel;

    4.      Abandoning the argument that 
            the allegations of vexatious, 
            unwelcome and poisoned work 
            environment called for an 
             objective test in order to 
             ground liability – a position he 
             supported when mentoring the 
             Applicant’s lead counsel before 
             the JPRC Hearing Panel;

  5.      Failing/refusing to raise at the 
           Divisional Court that a significant 
           part of the Notice of Hearing was 
           barred by the principle of law in 
           Hryciuk  v. Ontario only to raise
           it on the leave motion in this Court;

6.      Failing/refusing to raise the tainted 
         well doctrine of bias with respect to 
         the recusal of The Law Society of 
         Upper Canada’s nominee from the 
         Hearing Panel – erroneously asserting 
         in his Affidavit of January 3rd, 2018 
         that he did not raise it on judicial review 
         because it was not raised below;

7.      Failing/refusing to raise the 
         argument that the JPRC 
         Hearing Panel was  
         improperly constituted – 
         again erroneously asserting in 
         Exhibit II of his affidavit Of 
         January 3rd, 2108 that he did not 
         raise it because it was not raised 
         below when in fact it could not 
         have been raised below because 
         the disclosure was first made to him 
         after the tribunal’s decisions and the 
         Order-in-Council;
  
  8.      Failing to ensure that the Divisional 
           Court had a complete record of 
           proceedings and attempting to place 
           blame on the Applicant’s counsel who 
           was the subject of the JPRC referral to 
           the LSUC for this in his affidavit of 
           January 3rd, 2018;

 9.      Engaging in extensive conversation 
          with the investigator from the LSUC 
          on the JPRC referral between preparing 
          the memo on Presenting Counsel’s 
          conduct and serving and filing his 
          factum and Application Record in 
          January, 2016.

 10.    Refusing to raise numerous 
          serious excesses of Presenting 
          Counsel in the presentation of the 
          case against the Applicant detailed 
          in a November 8th, 2015 memo 
          which he admitted under cross
          -examination on February 8th, 
          2018 adversely impacted the 
          Applicant’s fair hearing rights.

 11.    Filing his facta and Application 
          Record before resolving the scope 
          of the record of proceedings contrary 
          to the Divisional Courts jurisprudence 
          where he has handled many such 
           applications.

 12.    Failing to discharge their duty of candour
          to the Applicant and to ensure that they
          properly advised him so that he could
          give an informed consent to their advice
          to him.                
                                               
 Presenting Counsel’s
Personal Conflict:

21.    Evidence before the Divisional Court panel on the Applicant’s motion indicated that he discovered in April 2017 that Presenting Counsel’s spouse was a law partner of the complainant former Presenting Counsel Doug Hunt.  Presenting Counsel did not call Mr. Hunt to give evidence and in fact when asked who the complainant was she advised that it was the witnesses she would call at the hearing. The Applicant relied on Presenting Counsel’s representation and questioned the witnesses on their intention to complain only for the Hearing Panel to rule that their intention was irrelevant as Mr. Hunt was determined to be the complainant only after the Hearing Panel’s liability decision was issued on January 12th, 2015.           
                                                           
22.    The Divisional Court ruled that neither the above or the other items of the fresh evidence adduced by the Applicant met the test for admission of fresh evidence on the motion.

 Fundamental Questions of
Law and Ethics Transcending
the parties:

23.   The Divisional Court Decision raises discrete issues about the role of the court, counsel and the Attorney General of Ontario on a judicial review application which merit consideration and clarification by this Honourable Court:

 1.      Did the Divisional Court construe the 
          Applicant’s Motion and Notice of 
          Constitutional Question asserting a
          miscarriage of justice before it too 
          narrowly ? 

 2.      Given the evidence before the Court 
          pointing to ineffective assistance of 
          counsel and conflict of interest which 
          deprived the Applicant of a fair hearing 
          before the Divisional Court and on his
          leave to appeal motion before this 
          Honourable Court did the Divisional 
          Court err in refusing to entertain this 
          evidence in  support of the Applicant’s 
          claim of a miscarriage of justice in
           the loss of judicial office ?

3.      Is there any principled reason why 
         ineffective assistance of  counsel in 
         the context of a judicial review application 
         pertaining to removal from judicial office 
         does not constitute facts arising or 
         discovered after an order is made 
         and constitutes an abuse of process merely 
         because the client relies on the same 
         lawyer on a leave to appeal motion ?

 4.     The Divisional Court’s decision is 
         inconsistent with jurisprudence from 
         the Supreme Court of Canada on tribunal 
         standing to defend its decisions and 
         boot-strapping, this court with respect 
         to the duty on a tribunal to file a complete 
         record on judicial review, the Federal 
        Court of Appeal and other courts with
        respect to the availability of ineffective 
        assistance of counsel as a basis for 
        establishing a breach of natural justice 
        and hence an unfair hearing in civil cases.

The following documentary evidence will be relied upon:


1.  Divisional Court Reasons dated April 9th, 2018;

2.  Motion Record originally filed with the Divisional Court will be
     Requisitioned;

3.   Such further evidence or documents which this Honourable Court may permit.




April 24th, 2018                                                                   

E. J. GUISTE
Professional Corporation
Trial & Appellate Advocacy
2 County Court Blvd., Suite 494
Brampton, Ontario
L6W 3W8
E.J. Guiste (LSUC # 34970C)
(416) 364-8908
(416) 364-0973 FAX
Counsel for the Applicant

   
Henein Hutchison LLP
235 King Street East, 3rd Floor
Toronto, Ontario
M5A 1J9

Tel.(416) 368-500 – Fax (416) 368-6640

Mr. S. Hutchison and Mr. M. Gourlay
Presenting Counsel and Counsel for the JPRC
In the Court Proceedings to Date


AND TO:

Ministry of the Attorney General for Ontario
Crown Law Office – Civil Law
720 Bay Street, 8th Floor
Toronto, Ontario
M7A 2S9

Tel. (416) 326-4155 – Fax (416) 326-4181
Ms. Sara Blake,  
Counsel for the Lieutenant Governor
In Council and the Attorney General

AND TO:

DEWART GLEASON LLP
102-366 Adelaide Street West
Toronto, Ontario
M5V 1R9

Tel.(416) 971-8000
Fax (416) 971-8001

Tim Gleason
Counsel for the Intervenor
AND TO:

The Attorney General of Canada (as required by s.109 of the Courts of Justice Act)
Suite 3400, Exchange Tower
Box 36, First Canadian Place
Toronto, Ontario
M5X 1K6

Fax (416) 952-0298

NOTE:  This Notice of Motion seeking leave to appeal was filed in the Court of Appeal for Ontario on April 24th, 2018.  It is published here because it raises issues of public importance. Is there any principled reason why a judicial officer removed from office is not entitled to effective assistance of counsel on a judicial review pursuant to the Judicial Review Procedures Act ?  Can a client give consent to circumstances giving rise to a conflict of interest and or divided loyalty on the part of his or her lawyer which impair his or her fair hearing rights ?     



Wednesday, April 18, 2018

Judicial Review:Some Insightful Quotes


[10]   An application for judicial review is not the same thing as an appeal.  Without getting too technical, it is sufficient to say that judicial review is a public law remedy by which the courts will oversee government decision-making even where the law does not provide an appeal to the unsuccessful party.  The common law and, now the Judicial Review Procedure Act provide for courts to become involved in processes of government in limited circumstances to ensure that certain fundamental rules of justice are maintained and to protect members of the public against government action that is inconsistent with established norms.

Zirger  v.  The Normal Farm Practices and Protection Board 2018 ONSC 2236 (Divisional Court)


"The very qualities which make the Agency well suited to determine questions within its area of specialization may lead it to overlook or underestimate general values which are fundamental to the legal order as a whole.  The generalist Court is ideally suited to check the specialist Agency at the point where these general values are threatened."

Peter W. Hogg - Judicial Review in Canada: How Much Do We Need It ?


"Where a tribunal fails to dispose of a matter before it in a manner permitted by the enabling legislation it is not functus officio.  When the said tribunal files a record of proceedings before a reviewing court which is incomplete for whatever reason neither the tribunal who fails to properly dispose of the matter or the reviewing court can be said to be functus officio - particularly in light of Rule 59 of the Rules of Civil Procedure.  Parties can not consent to make that which is relevant to the restoration of public confidence in the judicial removal process disappear."

E.J. Guiste - Applicant's Factum in Massiah v. JPRC et al at para 67


"Based on the record before it this Honourable Court found the subject tribunal's liability and penalty decisions to be reasonable."

"Judicial review is based on a tribunal's record of proceedings."

"The focus of this court's inquiry ought to be on the impact of the JPRC deficient record of proceedings on this court's order; the impact of Presenting Counsel's representation on the identify of the complainant on the fairness of the hearing; the impact of appellate counsel's failure to raise a litany of issues calling for a correctness standard of review; and lastly the overriding impact of the unconstitutionality of the challenged segments of the enabling legislation and the Procedures Document."

"Once approached from this point of view, the reality that this court's order of October 4th, 2016 must be set aside is inescapable since justice must be seen to be done. The appearance of bias and unfairness is just as important s the reality."

E.J. Guiste - Excerpts from Reply Factum in Massiah v. JPRC et al 


NOTE:  This piece is published here to draw attention to issues of public importance.  Judicial review is is not an appeal.  Judicial review is not a trial.  Judicial review is a unique procedure designed to provide the public with a forum and remedy for ensuring that government acts within the law.


Wednesday, April 11, 2018

New JPRC Panel Denies JP Public Hearing and "Rubber-stamps" Old Compensation Decision

ERROR 1: 


  If it wasn't enough that the JPRC failed to inform the Divisional Court that the 2012 Hearing Panel which that court ordered to rehear the compensation issue in Massiah v.  JPRC ONSC no longer existed prior to the court's order of October 4th, 2016, resulting in a two-member panel actively considering the case for some nine months only to conclude that they were "unable to make a unanimous decision" in their decision of October 25th, 2017 - they have managed to do it again.

ERROR 2:

    Over JP Massiah's objections, the 2/3s of the 2012 Panel went on to recommend to the Chief Justice that she appoint a new panel to hear the compensation issue. JP Massiah properly advised them that their jurisdiction was spent and assuming they have jurisdiction he would go with a new panel.  JP Massiah also questioned the utility of the exercise since under the governing legislation the Attorney General is not obligated to pay on their recommendation as is required with Ontario Court of Justice judges by virtue of s.51.7(8) of the Courts of Justice Act.

   Once again Presenting Counsel supported this move and went even further.  Presenting Counsel argued in written submissions on the issue that JP Massiah's appeal lawyer at the Divisional Court agreed that this was the proper way to proceed.  Interestingly, JP Massiah's appellate counsel told a different story in his sworn affidavit dated January 3rd, 2018.  In an e mail to JP Massiah which is Exhibit Y on his affidavit he stated, "I told him I would want to put that before the Divisional Court, before we took out the order, because otherwise the hearing panel would think they had a binding direction to re-hear the costs issue." 

   JP Massiah's appeal lawyer and counsel for the JPRC and the Attorney General overlooked the necessity of seeking directions from the Divisional Court in order to comply with the Divisional Court's October 4th, 2016 order.   

   An October 17th, 2016 Law Times publication on the case suggests that JP Massiah's appeal lawyer was very much aware of the compliance problems flowing from the retirement of Justice Livingstone.  It reads: "Anand says the Divisional Court ruling on the compensation issue will cause some practical difficulties, since Justice Deborah Livingstone, who chaired the second review council panel, has since retired from the bench." (Legal bill covered for fired justice of the peace ?)

   Presenting Counsel once again argued for and obtained a departure from the traditional obligatory public hearing over JP Massiah's objections. JP Massiah's request to call viva voce evidence was objected to by Presenting Counsel and denied by the new hearing panel chaired by Justice Lahaie.

ERROR 3:

   Justice Lahaie went on to rule that she had in her possession all of the written submissions made to the 2/3 of the 2012 Panel and that no further evidence or submissions would be received.  Among the cases in her possession from the earlier submissions made by JP Massiah included a Court of Appeal Case - Re Lovering and Minister of Highways [1965] 2 O.R. 721 (ONCA).

   In Re Lovering and Minister of Highways [1965] 2 O.R. 721(1965 Canli 276 (ONCA) the Court of Appeal was faced with a situation where a tribunal which had been ordered to rehear an issue refused to allow a party to adduce evidence and proceeded to effectively rubber-stamp their initial decision. The Court of Appeal held as follows:

"It was wrong for the Board on a rehearing ordered by the Court to decided the case on the record already before it and to refuse to hear further evidence. The matter must be referred back again and on the further rehearing the Board should be differently constituted."


NOTE:  This piece is published here to draw attention to various issues of public importance which arise in this case. The first is that orders of our courts are to be respected unless appealed. The Divisional Court rehearing order was not complied with.  Why ?  If the 2/3s of the 2012 Panel who undertook to comply with the Divisional Court's order was unable to decide the issue was it open to them to do anything other than to render their decision and for JPRC to seek directions from the court ? Second, if a public hearing is the presumptive right on these matters - why was JP Massiah denied this fundamental right ?  Third, if there is no obligation on the Attorney General to follow the tribunal's recommendation for compensation for legal fees under the legislation - how does the Attorney General justify paying JP Massiah's lawyers on his first hearing directly for a similar case ?  What was different, if anything, the first time around ?

The author, E.J. Guiste is currently counsel to JP Massiah in his efforts to remedy what he, his client and many observers see and believe to be a miscarriage  of justice and a glaring lack of consistency, fairness, impartiality and independence in the complaint process involving Ontario's justices of the peace. Any error in this publication ought to be brought to the writer's attention and it will be dealt with.     
  

Saturday, April 7, 2018

Copy of JP Massiah's Notice of Motion Asserting a Miscarriage of Justice

                                                                                                 
                                                                              Divisional Court File No. 316/15  
 ONTARIO
SUPRIOR COURT OF JUSTICE
DIVISIONAL COURT

ERROL MASSIAH
Applicant/Moving Party

-and-


THE JUSTICES OF THE PEACE REVIEW COUNCIL and THE LIEUTENANT GOVERNOR BY AND WITH THE ADVICE AND CONCURRENCE OF THE EXECUTIVE COUNCIL OF THE LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY FOR THE PROVINCE OF ONTARIO and THE ATTORNEY GENERAL FOR ONTARIO
Respondents

 NOTICE OF MOTION

          The Applicant, Errol Massiah, will bring a motion before the Divisional Court on a date to be fixed by the Registrar at 130 Queen Street West, Toronto, Ontario

Jurisdiction:

Rule 59.06(1), 59.06(2(a)(b) of the Rules of Civil Procedure, s.6(1) and 10 of the Judicial Review Procedures Act and s.20(d) of the Statutory Power Procedures Act and s.52(1) of the Constitution Act, 1982, including the Constitutional Principle of Judicial Independence

The Motion is for:

1.      An order amending, setting aside, varying or suspending 
the Divisional Court’s order of October 4th, 2016 upholding 
the findings of judicial misconduct and the recommendation to 
the Attorney General for the Applicant’s removal from judicial 
office by a Hearing Panel of the Justices of the Peace Review 
Council and Order in Council 546/2015 dated April 29, 2015;

2.      An order admitting the Applicant’s proposed fresh evidence;

3.      An order declaring appellate counsel for the Applicant in Divisional Court File No. 316/15 to have been in a personal conflict of interest on five fundamental grounds thereby depriving the Applicant of the right to counsel or the effective assistance of counsel rendering this Honourable Court’s orders and decision void or voidable;

4.      An order declaring the said Appellate Counsel to have provided ineffective counsel to the Applicant thereby depriving the Applicant of his constitutional right to a fair and impartial hearing of the review by a Superior Court of his removal from judicial office;
  
5.      An Order declaring that Presenting Counsel exceeded the statutory ambit of her duties as Presenting Counsel under the Justices of the Peace Review Council’s Procedures Document and in so doing deprived the Hearing Panel with the effective assistance of counsel and or improperly interfered with the Applicant’s right to counsel and   his right to defend his judicial office as is his constitutional right so to do;  

6.      An order declaring Henein Hutchison LLP to be in a conflict of interest and consequently disqualified from defending the decisions of the Justices of  the Peace Review Council Hearing Panel’s decisions in this matter since the challenged acts and omissions flow from their discharge of the function of Presenting Counsel before the Hearing Panel and the filling of the tribunal’s record of proceedings and it is for the Attorney General of Ontario to exercise his common law, constitutional and statutory jurisdiction under the Ministry of the Attorney General Act in the public interest;

7.      An order appointing a Case Management Judge to oversee and direct the proceedings between the parties.


 The Grounds for the Application are:

Decisions found to be Reasonable

1.      By order dated October 4th, 2016 a Divisional Court panel upheld an Order in Council dated April 29th, 2015 removing the Applicant from office as a Justice of the Peace finding the recommending tribunal’s liability and penalty decisions were reasonable and directing a rehearing for his claim for compensation of his legal costs with directions;

Decision Based on Admittedly
Deficient Record of Proceedings

2.      The legal soundness of that decision by the Divisional Court panel is undermined by the fact that the subject tribunal failed in its duty to file its complete record of proceedings with the court pursuant to the Judicial Review Procedures Act, the Statutory Powers Procedures Act and an order or agreement by the hearing panel itself expressly delineating the content of the “record for any further applications which could follow our decision”;

3.      Appellate counsel for the Applicant though recognizing the patent deficiency in the record of proceedings and alerting JPRC counsel to the deficiency relied upon the JPRC’s counsel’s undertaking to file the investigation transcripts as vol. 8-12 of their Application Record and he and all counsel proceeded with filing their facta and books of authorities with this court prior to delineating and resolving the issue of the record of proceedings contrary to this court’s established jurisprudence thereby depriving the Applicant of a fair hearing in this Honourable Court;

4.      The record of proceedings filed by the tribunal and Appellate Counsel for the Applicant with the Divisional Court lacked the following relevant documents:

1.      The Applicant’s written answer to the
         Complaints Committee’s notice of
         allegations from their investigation;

2.      The five volume investigation transcripts
         filed by the Applicant with the Hearing Panel
         and relied upon by the them in their Decision 
         of January 12th, 2015 at para 66;

 3.      Applicant’s sworn affidavit filed March 28th, 
          2014; (see para 142 of above-noted decision)

4.      Written submissions of the parties on jurisdiction 
          and abuse of process motion; (as above at para 3)

5.      Written submissions of the parties on liability;
         (see para 6 Reasons for Decision dated January 12, 2015)      

 6.      Written submissions of the parties on penalty;
           (see Decision on Disposition at para 28)


 7.      All facta, books of authorities, responding facta
          per Chair’s pronouncement October 8th, 2014

5.      The deficient record of proceedings filed with the court prevented the court from inquiring into “the qualities that make the decisions reasonable” and to inquire into the “existence of justification, transparency and intelligibility within the decision-making process and whether the decisions fall within a range of possible, acceptable outcomes which are defensible in law” as mandated by established and binding legal principles on this Honourable Court.                      
   
6.      The incomplete record prevented the Divisional Court from assessing both the correctness and reasonableness of various interlocutory motions brought on behalf of the Applicant challenging the following salient legal points reflected in the subject tribunal’s Decision on the Motion to Ban Publication, Decision on The Motion for Disclosure and Particulars, Decision on Bias and Decision on Jurisdiction and Alleged Abuses of Process,:

1.      Whether an interim publication ban should issue pending the 
         Hearing Panel’s adjudication of the Applicant’s and the 
         Hearing Panel’s motions on Jurisdiction and their 
         determination of who is the complainant;

 2.      Whether Presenting Counsel failed to discharge
          its mandatory disclosure obligation under paragraphs 10 and 
          11 of the Procedures Document by disclosing the name and 
          contact information for only those witnesses she intended to 
          call rather than all witnesses known to have knowledge of 
          the relevant facts – i.e. the 20 other witnesses interviewed by 
          the Complaints Committee during the investigation and the 
          “complainant” Mr. Doug Hunt who was not interviewed and 
          not called as a witness;
                                                                            
3.      Whether the Notice of Hearing was improper in that
          it exceeded the document determined to be the “complaint” 
          some 19 months after its issuance and material aspects of it 
          were never investigated by the Complaints Committee and 
          relied on propensity evidence and a “history of judicial
          misconduct” in paragraph 14 when the current allegations 
          pre-dated or were concurrent with the Applicant’s first 
          disposition and did not follow it;


 4.      Whether the Complaints Committee exceeded its
           authority in the investigations it undertook;

 5.      Whether the Applicant’s acts and omissions in his
          interactions with court staff met the objective test
          established by both this court and the Court of  Appeal 
          for Ontario for findings of “vexatious”, “unwelcome” 
          and creating a “poisoned work environment” and the 
          conclusion that he “acted in a manner inconsistent  
          with the Human Rights  Code”;

 6.      Whether the Hearing Panel exhibited a reasonable
          apprehension of bias against the Applicant and his
          counsel, Ernest J. Guiste both during and post
          hearing when the Chair of the Hearing 
          Panel retweeted a Toronto Sun article published 
          the day following their release of the Compensation 
          Decision and Addendum entitled “Fired JP Loses 
          Bid to Have Taxpayers Pay Legal Fees – 
          Lawyer’s Conduct to be Reviewed.
                                                                          
7.      The incomplete record deprived the Applicant of the ability to raise serious legal errors involving the interpretation and application of the Human Rights Code and this court’s decision in Hryciuk  v. Ontario 31 O.R. (3d) 1 – indeed although Presenting Counsel relied upon human rights authorities to ground liability against the Applicant before the Hearing Panel the issue of the interpretation and application of the Code is not in the record filed with the court and consequently not addressed by the parties before the court to the Applicant’s detriment;

8.      The incomplete record also impacted the nature and quality of assistance the Respondents and particularly the Attorney General could provide to the court with the important question of whether the tribunal’s decisions were within jurisdiction and in compliance with the rules of natural justice, fairness and the law of Ontario – especially the Human Rights Code - pursuant to the Attorney General’s statutory duty under s.5(c) and (i) of the Ministry of the Attorney General Act;

9.      Through no fault of the Applicant this most Honourable Court’s decision and order on his judicial review application was conducted in a manner which is contrary to The Rule of Law and in particular in contravention of the well established tradition and principle of the Open Court Doctrine – as relevant portions of the record of proceedings clearly relied upon by the subject tribunal were not before the court. 


Fresh Evidence

10.    Conflict of Interest:

Applicant’s Appellate
Counsel

(1)     Applicant’s appellate counsel’s retainer was contingent upon his conduct of a conflict of interest search which was never done;

(2)     Applicant’s appellate counsel relationship with a former 
panel member who voluntarily recused herself from the Hearing 
Panel on account of the Applicant’s concerns about bias 
compromised his defence of the Applicant and her reliance on 
the Hearing Panel’s disposition in a case she was adjudicating 
without acknowledgment that the disposition decision was under 
review by this Honourable Court destroyed the necessary 
appearance of transparency and fairness in the proceedings;

(3)     Applicant’s appellate counsel mentored counsel, Ernest J. Guiste at the proceedings before the Hearing Panel and received the appellate referral from Mr. Guiste, who both appellate counsel and his law firm have had a solicitor-client relationship with on four separate retainers, including the following:

1.  (1990) Academic appeal – University of Windsor
2.  (        )  Poponne   v.  Guiste
3.  (2002) Walsh  v. 1124660 Ontario Limited 2002 Canli 4980 
4.   (2016) Green  v. Guiste

          and as a result the Applicant reasonably understood that appellate counsel was duty-bound to vigorously defend all the allegations made by the Hearing Panel against Mr. Guiste and himself or decline his retainer;

(4)     Applicant’s appellate counsel failed to disclose to him that in and around 2008 he had been appointed by the Government of Ontario as the Chair, Board of Directors of the Human Rights Legal Support Centre attached to the Human Rights Tribunal to advocate on behalf of victims of discrimination and harassment;

(5)     Failed to inform the Applicant of his decision in a case which sitting as a Board of Inquiry under the Human Rights Code which objectively compromised his ability to advocate the Human Rights Code issues forcefully on behalf of the Applicant, namely, Hom et al  v.  Impact Interiors et al BOI Decision #93-058.

11.    Ineffective Assistance
          of Counsel:

Applicant’s Counsel:

1.     overlooked or refused to take the 
        Applicant’s instruction to raise bias 
        as a ground of review;

2.     overlooked or refused to take the 
        Applicant’s instruction to challenge
        the Hearing Panel’s error in its 
        interpretation and application of the 
        Human Rights Code principles of 
        “vexatious”, “unwelcome” and  
        “poisoned work environment”;

3.      overlooked or refused to take the
         Applicant’s instruction to challenge
         the Hearing Panel’s erroneous interpretation
         and application of Hryciuk  v. Ontario;

4.      Although he prepared a memorandum on the
         flagarent excesses of Presenting Counsel
         in the discharge of her office and received
         the Applicant’s authorization to assert those
         clear excesses as a breach of natural justice
         adversely impacting his fair hearing rights –
         he failed to advance this ground of error;

5.      Although recognizing a clear deficiency in 
         the “Record of Proceedings filed by counsel 
         for the JPRC and the need to supplement 
         it, proceeded to serve and file a factum and 
         reply factum on behalf of the Applicant 
         without first resolving the issue of the 
         sufficiency of the record in accord with 
         this court’s jurisprudence;
                                            
6.      Entered into an unauthorized agreement 
         with counsel for the JPRC to surpress 
         documents referred to and relied upon by 
         the Hearing Panel in making its decisions 
         from the “record of proceedings” to not 
         only the Applicant’s detriment but the court 
         and public’s detriment as the Applicant’s 
         removal from judicial office is presumptively 
         a matter of public importance and consequently 
         this agreement is of no force or effect being 
         in contravention of the Open Court Principle;

7.      Failed to seek costs on behalf of the Applicant
         despite knowing of his impecunious state.
         
Presenting Counsel
Conflict of Interest:             
         
12.    On April 14th, 2017 the Applicant learned that current Presenting Counsel, Ms. Marie Henein’s spouse was a law partner of the complainant, former Presenting Counsel, Mr. Doug Hunt, in and around the material time of Mr. Hunt acting as Presenting Counsel before Justice Vallencourt and the date of his report to his instructing counsel, Ms. Marilyn King, Registrar and Counsel to the JPRC thereby tainting the objective requirement of fairness in the proceedings contrary to law;

Fresh Evidence that “Complainant”
Former Assistant Attorney General
For Ontario:

13.    On April 14th, 2017 the Applicant learned that prior to going into the private practice of law the “complainant”, prior Presenting Counsel, Mr. Hunt was Assistant Deputy Attorney General for Ontario;

Ineffective Assistance of
Counsel by Presenting Counsel:

14.    Appointed Presenting Counsel exceeded the jurisdiction granted by the JPRC Procedures Document in the execution of her public duty  and deprived the Applicant of a fair and impartial hearing of the complaint initiated by prior Appointed Presenting Counsel, Mr. Hunt.

15.    In addition, Presenting Counsel provided an incorrect instruction to the Hearing Panel on the interpretation and application of the Human Rights Code, Hryciuk  v. Ontario and the source of their jurisdiction being her Notice of Hearing as distinct from the complaint under s. 11.1(10) of the Justices of the Peace Act – instructions which the Hearing Panel followed and improperly applied in finding that the Applicant committed judicial misconduct and that this misconduct required a recommendation for his removal from office.

Non-Compliance with
Mandatory Statutory
Requirements:

16.    During the Applicant’s hearing before the JPRC Hearing Panel, the issue of who is the “complainant” and whether the mandatory requirements prescribed by the Justices of the Peace Act, and Procedures Document were complied with was a central issue before the Hearing Panel as is evident in their Decision on Jurisdiction and
Alleged Abuses of Process.

(a)     The JPRC Hearing Panel ruled on January 12th, 2015 – some 20 months after the Notice of Hearing was issued on May 31st, 2013 that former Presenting Counsel, Mr. Hunt, was the complainant. Current Presenting Counsel did not call former Presenting Counsel, Mr. Hunt, to testify that in submitting a report to his instructing counsel, the Registrar, Ms. Marilyn King, he intended to make a complaint about the Applicant’s judicial conduct. Further, current Presenting Counsel failed to provide the Applicant with Mr. Hunt’s name and particulars pursuant to her disclosure obligations.

(b)     Current Presenting Counsel told the Applicant that the “complainants” in his case were witnesses who would be come to testify in a letter dated January 14th, 2014, which letter was part of the Applicant Motion Record on his motion asserting a reasonable apprehension of bias. Accordingly, the Applicant cross-examined witnesses on this information to his detriment – the Hearing Panel ruling that their intention was not relevant as Mr. Hunt was the complainant.

(c)     After the findings of liability, disposition and compensation, the Registrar and Presenting Counsel’s instructing counsel, Ms. King, prepared an affidavit sworn August 19th, 2016 in which she deposed that she – as distinct from the Complaints Committee, complied with one of the two mandatory requirement of notice to complainants, namely that the “complaint” was proceeding to a hearing and that his evidence may be required and although this evidence was never properly made part of the “record of proceedings” before this Honourable Court, resulted in an amendment to the Applicant’s factum.

(d)     The JPRC has not disclosed an acknowledgment of receipt of the “complaint” from the Complaints Committee to date and the Complaints Committee never filed a “report” with the JPRC contrary to both mandatory requirements stipulated by s.11(3) and 11(18) of the Justices of the Peace Act.

17.    The Applicant, who conscientiously believes himself to have been wrongly removed from his judicial office and to be a victim of a “miscarriage of justice” desires the fastest and most economically efficient resolution of his legal matters in the public interest;

18.    The proposed fresh evidence meets the criteria set out by the Supreme Court of Canada in R  v. Palmer [1980] 1 S.C.R. 759;          

19.    Rule 1.04(1), 1.04(2), s.6(1) and s.10 of the Judicial Review Procedures Act, s.20(d) of the Statutory Procedures Act, s.5(c) (i) of the Ministry of the Attorney General Act, The Human Rights Code, The Justices of the Peace Act and The Procedures Document, The Constitution Act, 1982 and the Constitutional Principle of Judicial Independence, U.N. Basic Principles on the Independence of the Judiciary para 1, 2, 12, 17, 18, 19, and 20, and U.N. Basic Principles on the Role of Lawyers para 1, 14, 15, 18, 19.


The following documentary evidence will be relied upon:

1.      Divisional Court’s order dated October 4, 2016 and Reasons

2.      JPRC Hearing Panel Decisions on Liability, Penalty and Compensation;

3.      JPRC Hearing Panel Interlocutory Decisions on Publication 
Ban, Disclosure and Particulars, Bias, Jurisdiction and Abuse of Process

4.      Complaints Committee’s Investigation Transcripts

5.      Registrar’s Letter to Applicant providing notice of allegations and inviting a written answer;

6.      Applicant’s written Answer to Complaints Committee

7.      Notice of Hearing issued May 31st, 2013 by JPRC

8.      Order in Council 546/2015

9.      JPRC’s Motion Record RE: Fresh Evidence

10.    Presenting Counsel’s list of authorities and written submissions inviting liability before Hearing Panel based on the Human Rights Code(The Code)

11.    Presenting Counsel’s list of authorities and written submissions inviting removal based on The Code and the Hryciuk Removal Decision which was overturned by the Court of Appeal for Ontario on the very basis which the Applicant was asserting       before the Hearing Panel and which appellate counsel failed to raise in this Honourable Court;

12.    Presenting Counsel’s erroneous instruction on the interpretation and application of Hryciuk v.  Ontario 31 O.R. (3d) 1 (ONCA) at para 24 of their March 13th, 2014 submissions which instruction was relied upon by the Hearing Panel and appellate counsel overlooked;

12.    JPRC’s list of authorities before this Honourable Court;

13.    Excerpt of the October 8th, 2014 transcript where Presenting   Counsel acknowledged that paragraph 14 of the Notice of   Hearing she drafted was intended to be for disposition;

14.    JPRC’s Motion Record Re: Fresh Evidence dated August 23, 2016 and supporting affidavits

15.    Sworn affidavit of Mr. Errol Massiah and exhibits thereto

16.    Such further evidence or documents which this Honourable Court may permit.

Time Estimate:  

1-2 days (could change with case-management and admissions by the Respondents 
and appellate counsel)  



September 20th, 2017                                                            

E.J. Guiste (LSUC # 34970C)
E.J. GUISTE PROFESSIONAL CORPORATION
2 COUNTY COURT BLVD., SUITE 494
BRAMPTON, ONTARIO
L6W 3W8
(416) 364-8908
(416) 364-0973 FAX
Counsel for the Applicant

Henein Hutchison LLP
235 King Street East, 3rd Floor
Toronto, Ontario
M5A 1J9

Tel.(416) 368-500 – Fax (416) 368-6640
Ms. M. Henein, Mr. S. Hutchison and Mr. M. Gourlay
Presenting Counsel and Counsel for the JPRC
In the Court Proceedings to Date

AND TO:

Ministry of the Attorney General for Ontario
Crown Law Office – Civil Law
720 Bay Street, 8th Floor
Toronto, Ontario
M7A 2S9

Tel. (416) 326-4155 – Fax (416) 326-4181
Ms. Sara Blake, and Mr. Brent Kettles
Counsel for the Lieutenant Governor
In Council and the Attorney Gene

NOTE:  This is a copy of the legal document which was filed with the Divisional Court asserting a miscarriage of justice and requesting that Court to set aside its Order of October 4th, 2016. It is published here on account of its public interest value.  These issues ought never to be litigated in private. The public has not only a right to know but a right to see the court documents and especially the record of proceedings.